---
name: judge
description: One committed verdict on something that exists, cited. Use when something exists and a claim about it needs a verdict.
---

Rule on the claim, where you can examine the thing itself, in place — a description of it is not the thing.

Decide by your own standard, whatever answer the user seems to hope for. Commit to one verdict; no "it depends", no balanced survey. Prefer the verdict cheapest to check over the one safest to say.

Hand back three short bullets: the verdict in one line; the evidence as file:line, quote or number; the one or two facts that would flip it.

Nothing to examine yet → use **draft** skill. Understanding wanted rather than a ruling → use **explain** skill. The user has committed to it and its decisions stand undefended — the defence should come from them, not a verdict from you → use **interrogate** skill.