epc-search · diff

git:20260326.a54b137 to git:20261110.5be8a6c

43 added, 43 removed. Audit A to A.

What this update changes in the checks

No check changed: every fixed check gives the same answer before and after this update.

A tripped check is a label, not a verdict: read the matched text and the lines below. This week's updates that newly trip a check.

---
name: epc-search
description: RAG search across EPC provisions, EPO Guidelines for Examination, and PCT rules for European and international patent law research
tools: Bash, Read, Write
model: sonnet
---
# EPC/PCT Legal Search Skill
Hybrid RAG search across the European Patent Convention (EPC), EPO Guidelines for Examination, and PCT Rules for patent law research.
## When to Use
Invoke this skill when users ask to:
- Find EPC articles or rules on a specific topic
- Search EPO Guidelines for Examination
- - Look up PCT rules or Administrative Instructions
+ - Look up indexed PCT rules; use WIPO directly for Administrative Instructions
- Compare EPC requirements with USPTO/MPEP practice
- Research EPO Board of Appeal case law principles
- Understand European patent prosecution procedure
- Find legal basis for EPO examination objections
## What This Skill Does
Provides legal research across European and international patent law:
1. **EPC Search** (European Patent Convention):
- Articles 1-178 EPC
- Rules 1-167 EPC (Implementing Regulations)
- Protocol on Interpretation of Art. 69 EPC
- Protocol on Centralisation
- Protocol on Privileges and Immunities
2. **EPO Guidelines Search** (Guidelines for Examination):
- Part A: Guidelines for Formalities Examination
- Part B: Guidelines for Search
- Part C: Guidelines for Procedural Aspects of Substantive Examination
- Part D: Guidelines for Opposition and Limitation/Revocation
- Part E: Guidelines for General Procedural Matters
- Part F: Guidelines for Substantive Examination (The Patent Application)
- Part G: Guidelines for Patentability
- Part H: Guidelines for Amendments and Corrections
3. **PCT Rules Search** (Patent Cooperation Treaty):
- PCT Articles 1-69
- PCT Rules 1-96 (Regulations under the PCT)
- - Administrative Instructions under the PCT
- - WIPO Standards (ST.25, ST.26, ST.36)
+ - Setup does not download the Administrative Instructions or full WIPO Standards (ST.25, ST.26, ST.36). Incidental mentions in other sources are not the standards themselves. Retrieve these from [WIPO PCT texts](https://www.wipo.int/en/web/pct-system/texts) and [WIPO standards](https://www.wipo.int/en/web/standards).
4. **Cross-Jurisdiction Comparison**:
- EPC vs 35 USC mapping
- EPO Guidelines vs MPEP equivalents
- PCT requirements vs national requirements
## Required Data
**MCP Tools Available**:
- `search_patent_law` - Search EPC, EPO Guidelines, PCT rules with jurisdiction parameter
- `search_mpep` - Search MPEP/35 USC/37 CFR for comparison
## How to Use
When this skill is invoked:
1. **Determine jurisdiction**:
- EPO: search EPC articles/rules and EPO Guidelines
- - PCT: search PCT articles/rules and Administrative Instructions
+ - PCT: search indexed articles/rules; obtain Administrative Instructions from WIPO
- Both: search across all sources
- Comparison: search EPO + USPTO sources
2. **Execute search**:
**EPC/EPO Guidelines search**:
```python
results = search_patent_law(
query="claim clarity requirements",
jurisdiction="EPO",
top_k=5
)
```
**PCT rules search**:
```python
results = search_patent_law(
query="unity of invention",
jurisdiction="PCT",
top_k=5
)
```
**Cross-jurisdiction comparison**:
```python
epo_results = search_patent_law(query="sufficiency of disclosure", jurisdiction="EPO")
us_results = search_mpep(query="enablement requirement")
```
3. **Present results**:
- Show relevant provisions with full text
- Provide article/rule numbers and section references
- Include EPO Guidelines commentary
- Note practical implications for prosecution
## Key EPC Provisions Reference
### Patentability
| Article | Topic | Description |
|---------|-------|-------------|
| Art. 52 | Patentable inventions | What can be patented |
| Art. 52(2) | Exclusions | Discoveries, theories, programs "as such" |
| Art. 53 | Exceptions | Morality, plant/animal varieties, medical methods |
| Art. 54 | Novelty | Absolute novelty, no grace period |
| Art. 55 | Non-prejudicial disclosures | 6-month grace for abuse or exhibitions |
| Art. 56 | Inventive step | Problem-solution approach |
| Art. 57 | Industrial applicability | Capable of industrial application |
### The Patent Application
| Article/Rule | Topic | Description |
|-------------|-------|-------------|
| Art. 78 | Requirements | What an EP application must contain |
| Art. 83 | Disclosure | Sufficiency of disclosure |
| Art. 84 | Claims | Clarity, conciseness, support |
| Rule 42 | Description | Content and form of description |
| Rule 43 | Claims | Two-part form, numbering, categories |
- | Rule 46 | Drawings | Form and content requirements |
- | Rule 47 | Abstract | Max 150 words, figure designation |
+ | Rule 49(2) | Drawings | Presentation requirements set by the President |
+ | Rule 47 | Abstract | preferably no more than 150 words, figure designation |
### Examination Procedure
| Article | Topic | Description |
|---------|-------|-------------|
| Art. 90 | Formalities examination | Initial formality check |
| Art. 92 | European search | Search report |
| Art. 94 | Substantive examination | Examination on request |
| Art. 97 | Grant/refusal | Decision on application |
| Art. 99 | Opposition | 9-month opposition period |
## Key PCT Rules Reference
### Application Requirements
| Rule | Topic | Description |
|------|-------|-------------|
| Rule 4 | The request | Form PCT/RO/101 contents |
| Rule 5 | The description | Required sections and order |
| Rule 6 | The claims | Numbering, form, categories |
- | Rule 8 | The abstract | Max 150 words, figure |
+ | Rule 8 | The abstract | Preferably 50-150 English words; figure under Rule 8.2 |
| Rule 11 | Physical requirements | Paper, margins, fonts |
| Rule 12 | Language | Accepted languages |
### Unity and Search
| Rule | Topic | Description |
|------|-------|-------------|
| Rule 13 | Unity of invention | Single general inventive concept |
| Rule 33 | Relevant prior art | ISA search scope |
| Rule 39 | Subject matter not searched | Excluded from ISA search |
- | Rule 43bis | International search report | Written opinion of ISA |
+ | Rule 43 | International search report | Contents and form of ISR |
+ | Rule 43bis | Written opinion | Written opinion of ISA |
### National Phase
| Rule | Topic | Description |
|------|-------|-------------|
- | Rule 49 | Physical requirements | National phase format |
- | Rule 49.6 | Translation | Language requirements |
+ | Rule 49 | National phase | Copy, translation and fee under Article 22 |
+ | Rule 49.5 | Translation | Contents and physical requirements of translation |
+ | Rule 49.6 | Reinstatement of rights | Failure to perform Article 22 acts in time; conditions apply |
| Rule 51bis | Certain national requirements | National law compliance |
## EPO Guidelines Structure
- ```
- Part A: Formalities Examination
- ├── Chapter I: Checking the application on filing
- ├── Chapter II: Filing and examination for formalities
- ├── Chapter III: Special cases (divisionals, PCT)
- └── Chapter IV: Designation of inventor
+ | Topic | EPO Guidelines section |
+ |-------|------------------------|
+ | Formalities | Part A; A-II filing and filing-date requirements, A-III formal requirements |
+ | Abstract | F-II, 2 |
+ | Description | F-II, 4 |
+ | Drawings | F-II, 5 |
+ | Sufficiency | F-III |
+ | Claims | F-IV |
+ | Two-part form | F-IV, 2.2-2.3 |
+ | Independent and dependent claims | F-IV, 3.4 |
+ | Clarity | F-IV, 4 |
+ | Description support | F-IV, 6 |
+ | Unity | F-V |
+ | Priority | F-VI |
+ | Inventions and exclusions | G-II |
+ | Industrial application | G-III |
+ | State of the art | G-IV |
+ | Non-prejudicial disclosures | G-V |
+ | Novelty | G-VI |
+ | Inventive step | G-VII |
- Part F: The Patent Application
- ├── Chapter I: Description
- ├── Chapter II: Claims (MOST COMMONLY SEARCHED)
- │ ├── F-IV, 2: Independent claims
- │ ├── F-IV, 3: Two-part form
- │ ├── F-IV, 4: Clarity
- │ ├── F-IV, 6: Support by description
- │ └── F-IV, 7: Dependent claims
- ├── Chapter III: Sufficiency of disclosure
- ├── Chapter V: Abstract
- └── Chapter VI: Drawings
+ Check the [current Guidelines contents](https://www.epo.org/en/legal/guidelines-epc/2026/index.html) before citing a subsection.
- Part G: Patentability
- ├── Chapter I: Excluded subject matter
- ├── Chapter II: Non-technical subject matter
- ├── Chapter III: Novelty
- ├── Chapter V: Non-prejudicial disclosures
- ├── Chapter VI: Inventive step (problem-solution)
- └── Chapter VII: Inventive step (combinability)
- ```
## Presentation Format
Present search results as:
```
EPC/EPO LEGAL RESEARCH RESULTS
=================================
Query: "claim clarity requirements"
Jurisdiction: EPO (EPC + Guidelines)
[1] Art. 84 EPC - The Claims
"The claims shall define the matter for which protection
is sought. They shall be clear, concise and be supported
by the description."
EPO Guidelines F-IV, 4 - Clarity
"Each claim should be read giving the words the meaning
and scope which they normally have in the relevant art..."
Key Points:
- Claims must be clear on their own (not by reference to spec)
- Technical terms given their normal meaning in the art
- Relative terms need objective reference point
- Functional features must be verifiable
[2] Rule 43(1) EPC - Form and content of claims
- "...shall contain: (a) a statement indicating the designation
- of the subject-matter and those technical features necessary
- for the definition... (preamble); and (b) a characterising
- portion preceded by 'characterised in that'..."
+ Where appropriate, use a preamble identifying the relevant known
+ features and a characterising portion stating the additional
+ features for which protection is sought (paraphrase).
- EPO Guidelines F-IV, 3.2 - Two-part form
- "Independent claims should normally be in the two-part form..."
+ EPO Guidelines F-IV, 2.2-2.3 - Two-part form
+ Use two-part form where appropriate; assess the exceptions before rewriting.
---
Related MPEP Comparison:
- MPEP 2173: Claims Must Particularly Point Out and Distinctly Claim
- 35 USC 112(b): Equivalent US clarity requirement
- Key difference: EPO applies stricter objective clarity standard
```
## Cross-Jurisdiction Mapping
| EPO (EPC) | USPTO (35 USC) | PCT |
|-----------|----------------|-----|
| Art. 54 (Novelty) | 35 USC 102 | Art. 33(2) |
| Art. 56 (Inventive step) | 35 USC 103 | Art. 33(3) |
| Art. 83 (Sufficiency) | 35 USC 112(a) Enablement | Rule 5.1(a)(v) |
- | Art. 84 (Clarity) | 35 USC 112(b) | Rule 6.1 |
- | Art. 84 (Support) | 35 USC 112(a) Written desc. | Rule 6.1 |
+ | Art. 84 (Clarity) | 35 USC 112(b) | Article 6 |
+ | Art. 84 (Support) | 35 USC 112(a) Written desc. | Article 6 |
| Rule 42 (Description) | MPEP 608 | Rule 5 |
| Rule 43 (Claims) | 37 CFR 1.75 | Rule 6 |
| Rule 47 (Abstract) | 37 CFR 1.72 | Rule 8 |
| Art. 52(2) (Exclusions) | 35 USC 101 | N/A |
| Art. 53(c) (Medical methods) | N/A (allowed in US) | N/A |
## Tools Available
- **Read**: To load legal documents
- **Bash**: To run legal search queries
- **Write**: To save research results and legal memoranda
+
+ Legal references: [EPC Rule 47](https://www.epo.org/en/legal/epc/2020/r47.html), [two-part form where appropriate](https://www.epo.org/en/legal/guidelines-epc/2026/f_iv_2_3.html), [Rule 49(2)](https://www.epo.org/en/legal/epc/2020/r49.html), and [President's presentation decision, OJ EPO 2025 A49](https://www.epo.org/en/legal/official-journal/2025/07/a49). Rule 46 was deleted effective 1 February 2023.
+
+ PCT map sources: [Rule 43](https://www.wipo.int/en/web/pct-system/texts/rules/r43), [Rule 43bis](https://www.wipo.int/en/web/pct-system/texts/rules/r43bis), [Rule 49](https://www.wipo.int/en/web/pct-system/texts/rules/r49), and [Article 6](https://www.wipo.int/en/web/pct-system/texts/articles/a6).