interrogate · diff
git:20261107.ded621a to git:20261107.b1f6e0c
8 added, 6 removed. Audit A to A.
What this update changes in the checks
No check changed: every fixed check gives the same answer before and after this update.
A tripped check is a label, not a verdict: read the matched text and the lines below. This week's updates that newly trip a check.
---
name: interrogate
description: "Adversarial pass over a diff or design: three reviewers on different models each try to break it — correctness, security, edge cases — findings merged by severity into a blocking verdict. For contested or high-risk changes."
aliases: []
metadata:
credits:
adversarial-panel: pstack
author: Lauren Tan
url: "https://github.com/cursor/plugins/tree/main/pstack"
port: pstack-claude
port-author: Michael Denyer
port-url: "https://github.com/michael-denyer/pstack-claude"
---
# Interrogate
Three independent reviewers try to break the work before it ships. Diversity
is the mechanism: reviewers on different models or provider families find
different classes of defects, and agreement across them is high-signal. This
is an adversarial lane on top of `review`, not a replacement for it.
## When to use
- a diff or design is contested, high-risk, or security-adjacent
- work is about to ship and a single review pass is not enough evidence
- the user asks to "stress-test", "red-team", or "try to break" a change
## When not to use
- routine changes with passing verification — `review` alone is enough
- the deliverable is an answer, not an artifact under judgment
## Phase 1 — Frame the target
Name exactly what is under interrogation: the diff (default), a design doc,
or an API contract. State the invariants the change must preserve; reviewers
attack those first.
## Phase 2 — Seat the panel
Spawn three reviewers in one message, in the background, each read-only:
- - prefer different models, and where available different provider families
- (Claude + Codex + Gemini via
+ - seat the panel for model diversity: read `team.roleRouting` from the
+ project config (`.claude/omc.jsonc`) or the user config
+ (`claude-omc/config.jsonc`; `omc config` prints the effective values) and
+ collect up to three distinct provider families in canonical role order,
+ filling any remaining seats from the default families — claude, codex,
+ gemini — not already seated, and say which family each seat got. When no
+ routing config exists, fall back to
`OMC_TEAM_WORKTREE_MODE=detached omc team --no-decompose 1:claude,1:codex,1:gemini "<the framed target, the invariants, and one lens per seat>"`,
or in-session `Task` dispatches to `oh-my-claudecode:code-reviewer` and
- `oh-my-claudecode:security-reviewer` on different models) — the team
+ `oh-my-claudecode:security-reviewer` on different models — the team
command needs the task text; pass target, invariants, and lens allocation
as that task
- each reviewer gets the same target by path, the invariants, and one lens:
correctness, security and trust boundaries, or edge cases and failure modes
- - **wait for every reviewer to reach a terminal state and collect its output
- before Phase 3** — the team route starts workers asynchronously, and
- merging before they finish reports an empty panel; a worker that stalls
- **wait for every reviewer to reach a terminal state and collect its output
before Phase 3** — the team route starts workers asynchronously, and
merging before they finish reports an empty panel; a worker that stalls
past the stated interval is named as missing, not silently dropped. Keep
worktrees and team state alive through judging, and run
`omc team shutdown <team-name> --force` (the name the startup snapshot prints; --force skips the confirmation prompt)
only in the final cleanup step after verification, as the
arena skill sequences it
- instruct each to prove every finding with a run against the real code — a
failing test, a repro script, or command output that shows the wrong
behavior; for a design or plan, a prototype or a probe of the current
tree — and to leave out anything it did not run. No findings is a valid
result. Findings come back as
`{severity: blocker|major|minor, claim, evidence, location}` where the
evidence is the command and the output it printed — a finding without a
run is dropped
## Phase 3 — Merge
You own the merge. Collect the panels' findings, re-run each finding's
command yourself, and keep only what reproduces and breaks the invariants;
merge findings that share a root cause, and rank the rest by severity. A
claim two reviewers disagree on is a question for the code, not a vote —
resolve it by reading or running. In the reply, say how many findings each
reviewer produced and how many did not survive the rerun, so a clean panel
reads as a result, not a silence.
## Phase 4 — Verdict
- **block**: any blocker finding stands after re-reading the evidence. The
work goes back to the author lane with the finding list; nothing merges.
- **revise**: only major or minor findings. Fix-forward is safe.
- **pass**: no standing findings. Record the verdict with the reviewers'
models named, in the reply.
The verdict is advisory to `review` and to the human; it never merges or
gates delivery on its own. When interrogation blocks, say what would change
the verdict.
## Phase 5 — Cleanup
After the verdict is delivered, run `omc team shutdown <team-name> --force` (the
name the startup snapshot printed) unconditionally — on pass, revise,
block, and error paths alike. The panel's workers, tmux panes, team state,
and detached worktrees must not outlive the interrogation. Keep the target
checkout intact; only team-managed resources are cleaned.
## Rules
- Never count your own review as one of the three.
- A reviewer that cannot run (missing provider, agent limits) is named in the
verdict as missing; two reviewers still produce a verdict, one does not.
- Findings are about the artifact, not the author; keep the tone clinical.