threshold · diff

v1.1 to v2

428 added, 36 removed. Audit A to A.

What this update changes in the checks

No check changed: every fixed check gives the same answer before and after this update.

A tripped check is a label, not a verdict: read the matched text and the lines below. This week's updates that newly trip a check.

---
name: threshold
codename: THRESHOLD
- internal: Commitment Gateway
- version: 1.1
+ internal: Commitment Gateway v2.0
+ version: 2.0
tier: governance
-
trigger:
- "should we go with"
- "let's just do"
- "final decision"
- "any schema change"
- "any public API contract"
- "any irreversible deployment"
-
- description: Gates commitment on irreversible decisions by measuring reversal cost and enforcing proportional exploration depth.
-
+ description: Gates commitment on irreversible decisions by measuring reversal cost and enforcing proportional exploration depth. Now with reversal cost functions, commitment s, early warning signals, and mathematical depth metrics.
author: Kshitijpalsinghtomar
-
- tags:
- - decisions
- - irreversibility
- - commitment
- - gates
- - reversal-cost
-
+ tags: [decisions, irreversibility, commitment, gates, reversal-cost, s, early-warning, metrics]
artifacts:
- threshold-classification
- depth-requirement
- termination-gates
- exit-plan
-
+ - reversal-cost-function
+ - early-warning-signals
+ - phase-activation
composable_with:
- adversary
- diverge
- temporal
- conductor
+ - negative-space
+ - provenance
+ thinking_parameters:
+ require_reversal_cost_function: true
+ require_commitment_: true
+ require_early_warning: true
+ require_gate_enforcement: true
---
- # THRESHOLD — Commitment Gateway
+ # THRESHOLD v2.0 — Commitment Gateway (Premium)
+ > **Mathematical Compliance**: This skill implements the DEPTH-MATHEMATICS specification. It computes and outputs ADS phase activation, CEI components, SI components, cognitive traces (reversal cost function, commitment , early warning signals), and verifies Gates V1-V6. It provides the final commitment verdict for the Depth .
+
Not all decisions deserve the same depth. A CSS color choice and a database primary key choice are not the same decision — but without this skill, the model treats them with roughly equal cognitive investment.
- This skill creates the gate between thinking and committing. It measures the **reversal cost**, enforces proportional exploration, and requires an exit plan before any high-cost commitment.
+ This skill creates the gate between thinking and committing. It measures the **reversal cost**, enforces proportional exploration, and requires an exit plan before any high-cost commitment. **Now it quantifies reversal cost as a function, produces verifiable commitment s, and defines early warning signals.**
---
## The Failure Mode You Must Recognize
You are about to give a quick, confident answer to a decision that:
- Cannot be easily undone (database schema, public API, data deletion)
- Affects many people or systems (blast radius extends beyond the immediate scope)
- Was not explored proportionally (one approach considered, zero alternatives evaluated)
Uniform depth — treating all decisions with the same level of analysis — systematically under-invests in the decisions that matter most.
+ **New failure mode in v2.0:** **Reversal cost handwaving** — "hard to undo" without quantification. **Commitment theater** — gates that look strict but lack enforcement. **Early warning absence** — no observable signals to detect a wrong decision before it's too late.
+
---
## The Protocol
- ### Step 1 — CLASSIFY: Write the Reversal Cost
+ ### 0 — PARAMETERIZE: Read Thinking Parameters
+ Read `thinking_parameters`:
+ - `require_reversal_cost_function` (default true) — quantify reversal cost mathematically
+ - `require_commitment_` (default true) — produce verifiable commitment
+ - `require_early_warning` (default true) — define observable early warning signals
+ - `require_gate_enforcement` (default true) — enforce all gates before commitment
+
+ ---
+
+ ### Step 1 — CLASSIFY: Write the Reversal Cost Function
+
+ **NEW IN v2.0** — Reversal cost is not a category. It's a **function**.
+
```
THRESHOLD CLASSIFICATION
────────────────────────────────────────
Decision: [what is being decided — one sentence]
- Reversal cost: [Category 1 / 2 / 3 / 4]
- Category 1 — TRIVIAL (minutes, no coordination):
+ Reversal Cost Function R(t):
+ R(t) = C_fixed + C_variable(t) + C_opportunity(t) + C_risk(t)
+
+ Where:
+ C_fixed = [one-time costs: migration tooling, data transformation, downtime]
+ C_variable(t) = [ongoing costs: parallel run, dual-write, performance penalty]
+ C_opportunity(t) = [foregone benefits: what you can't do while reversing]
+ C_risk(t) = [probability × impact of reversal failure]
+
+ Parameters:
+ t = time since commitment [days]
+ R(0) = [immediate reversal cost]
+ R(30) = [cost at 30 days]
+ R(90) = [cost at 90 days]
+ R(365) = [cost at 1 year]
+ R(∞) = [permanent cost — if never fully reversible]
+
+ Reversal Timeline: [minutes / hours / days / weeks / months / never]
+ Blast Radius: [self / team / users / ecosystem]
+ Category: [1 / 2 / 3 / 4] — derived from R(∞)
+
+ Category 1 — TRIVIAL (R(∞) < $1K equivalent, minutes-hours):
Variable names, file organization, CSS values, config
- Category 2 — MODERATE (hours to days, some coordination):
+ Category 2 — MODERATE (R(∞) $1K-$100K, hours-days):
Indexes, internal API shapes, library versions, service boundaries
- Category 3 — EXPENSIVE (days to weeks, significant coordination):
+ Category 3 — EXPENSIVE (R(∞) $100K-$1M, days-weeks):
Database schemas, public API contracts, auth systems, data formats
- Category 4 — CATASTROPHIC (weeks to months, or impossible):
+ Category 4 — CATASTROPHIC (R(∞) > $1M or impossible, weeks-never):
Primary keys, data deletion, published standards, architecture at scale
- Reversal timeline: [minutes / hours / days / weeks / months / never]
- Blast radius: [self / team / users / ecosystem]
+ When uncertain between two categories, pick the higher one.
+ The cost of overthinking a reversible decision is wasted time.
+ The cost of underthinking an irreversible one is permanent damage.
+
────────────────────────────────────────
```
- **When uncertain between two categories, pick the higher one.** The cost of overthinking a reversible decision is wasted time. The cost of underthinking an irreversible one is permanent damage.
+ **Artifact:** The reversal cost function with parameters and category.
- **Artifact:** The classification. Step 2 uses this to set the required depth.
+ **CEI Component:** Reversal Cost Function (weight 4.0)
- ### Step 2 — SET REQUIRED DEPTH
+ ---
+ ### Step 2 — SET REQUIRED DEPTH (Proportional to Reversal Cost)
+
Based on the classification:
```
DEPTH REQUIREMENT
────────────────────────────────────────
Category 1 — STANDARD:
→ 1 approach is sufficient. Move fast.
→ Skip remaining steps. Deliver.
+ ADS Target: 0.20
Category 2 — ELEVATED:
→ 2 approaches minimum before committing.
→ Document rollback path (1-2 sentences).
→ Run G1-G3 gates (Step 3).
+ ADS Target: 0.45
Category 3 — MAXIMUM:
→ 3 approaches minimum (use DIVERGE skill).
→ Full ADVERSARY review of chosen approach.
→ Written rollback plan (Step 4).
→ Run ALL gates G1-G6 (Step 3).
+ ADS Target: 0.70
Category 4 — MAXIMUM-PLUS:
→ All Layer 0 skills activated (DEEP-THINK → DIVERGE → ADVERSARY).
→ No commitment without explicit user confirmation.
→ Written rollback plan with timeline and dependencies (Step 4).
→ Run ALL gates. No exceptions.
+ ADS Target: 0.85
+
────────────────────────────────────────
```
- **Artifact:** The depth requirement. Step 3 enforces it.
+ **Artifact:** The depth requirement with ADS targets.
+ ---
+
### Step 3 — RUN THE TERMINATION GATES
Before any answer ships at Category 2+, these gates must pass. Write the result for each required gate:
```
TERMINATION GATES
────────────────────────────────────────
G1 — Problem fidelity:
Can I restate the user's intent (not just their words)?
[PASS — restatement: ___] / [FAIL — unclear because ___]
G2 — Alternative coverage:
Were at least [2/3] materially different approaches considered?
[PASS — approaches: ___] / [FAIL — only [N] considered]
+ CIM Check: [CIM score ≥ 0.5? PASS/FAIL]
G3 — Assumption exposure:
Are critical assumptions named and rated (C2/C3 from EXCAVATE)?
[PASS — assumptions listed] / [FAIL — assumptions not surfaced]
G4 — Failure-mode analysis: (Category 3+ only)
Are failure paths identified, not just the happy path?
[PASS — failures: ___] / [FAIL — only happy path]
+ NEGATIVE-SPACE Check: [failure taxonomy complete? PASS/FAIL]
G5 — Reversibility plan: (Category 3+ only)
Is the exit plan written (Step 4)?
[PASS — plan written] / [FAIL — no exit plan]
+ Reversal Cost Function: [R(t) defined? PASS/FAIL]
G6 — Decision rationale: (Category 3+ only)
Can I explain why the chosen option beats alternatives under
THESE SPECIFIC constraints?
[PASS — because: ___] / [FAIL — generic reasoning]
+ PROVENANCE Check: [EC ≥ 0.5? PASS/FAIL]
+
+ G7 — Early warning signals: (Category 3+ only, NEW)
+ Are observable early warning signals defined?
+ [PASS — signals: ___] / [FAIL — no signals]
+ Monitoring Plan: [dashboards/alerts defined? PASS/FAIL]
+
+ G8 — Commitment : (Category 4 only, NEW)
+ Is the commitment written (Step 5)?
+ [PASS — written] / [FAIL — no ]
+ User Confirmation: [explicit confirmation received? PASS/FAIL]
+
────────────────────────────────────────
```
**Any FAIL → return to the relevant step and complete it before shipping.** The gate exists because coherence is not completion and confidence is not evidence.
**Artifact:** The gate results. Failed gates block delivery.
+ **CEI Component:** Termination Gates (weight 3.0)
+
+ ---
+
### Step 4 — WRITE THE EXIT PLAN (Category 3+ Only)
```
EXIT PLAN
────────────────────────────────────────
If this decision turns out wrong, reversal requires:
+ Reversal Cost Function: R(t) = [from Step 1]
+
Steps:
- 1. [specific action]
- 2. [specific action]
- 3. [specific action]
+ 1. [specific action — e.g., "disable feature flag X"]
+ 2. [specific action — e.g., "run migration script Y in reverse"]
+ 3. [specific action — e.g., "restore database from snapshot Z"]
+ 4. [specific action — e.g., "notify stakeholders via channel W"]
+ 5. [specific action — e.g., "verify system health via dashboard V"]
- Timeline: [estimated reversal time]
- Data risk: [what could be lost or corrupted during reversal]
+ Timeline: [estimated reversal time at t=0, t=30, t=90]
+ R(0): [time]
+ R(30): [time]
+ R(90): [time]
+
+ Data Risk: [what could be lost or corrupted during reversal]
+ Data Loss Risk: [NONE / LOW / MEDIUM / HIGH]
+ Corruption Risk: [NONE / LOW / MEDIUM / HIGH]
+ Recovery Procedure: [how to recover if corruption occurs]
+
Dependencies: [what/who must coordinate]
- Early signal: [what observable sign indicates this decision is going wrong]
+ Internal Teams: [list]
+ External Vendors: [list]
+ User Communication: [required?]
+
+ Early Signals: [what observable sign indicates this decision is going wrong]
+ Signal 1: [metric/threshold] — Detection: [dashboard/alert] — Action: [what to do]
+ Signal 2: [metric/threshold] — Detection: [dashboard/alert] — Action: [what to do]
+ Signal 3: [metric/threshold] — Detection: [dashboard/alert] — Action: [what to do]
+
+ Monitoring Plan:
+ Dashboards: [list]
+ Alerts: [list]
+ Review Cadence: [daily/weekly/monthly]
+ Owner: [role/person]
+
────────────────────────────────────────
```
**If you cannot write the exit plan — you don't understand the decision well enough to make it.** Return to exploration.
+ **Artifact:** The exit plan with reversal cost function, timeline, data risk, dependencies, early signals, and monitoring plan.
+
+ **CEI Component:** Exit Plan (weight 4.0)
+
---
+ ### Step 5 — COMMITMENT (Category 4 Only, NEW)
+
+ **NEW IN v2.0** — Verifiable, auditable commitment record.
+
+ ```
+ COMMITMENT
+ ────────────────────────────────────────
+ ID: cc_<timestamp>_<hash>
+ Decision: [what is being committed to]
+ Category: [4 — CATASTROPHIC]
+ Reversal Cost: R(∞) = [value] — [Category 4 justification]
+
+ Chosen Option: [name]
+ Alternatives Considered: [list with CIM scores]
+ Option A: [name] — CIM: 0.XX — Rejected because: [specific]
+ Option B: [name] — CIM: 0.XX — Rejected because: [specific]
+
+ Gate Results:
+ G1: PASS — [restatement]
+ G2: PASS — [approaches, CIM: 0.XX]
+ G3: PASS — [assumptions]
+ G4: PASS — [failures]
+ G5: PASS — [exit plan, R(t)]
+ G6: PASS — [rationale, EC: 0.XX]
+ G7: PASS — [early signals]
+ G8: PASS — [this ]
+
+ Early Warning Signals:
+ 1. [metric] ≥ [threshold] → [action]
+ 2. [metric] ≥ [threshold] → [action]
+ 3. [metric] ≥ [threshold] → [action]
+
+ Monitoring:
+ Dashboard: [URL]
+ Alerts: [list]
+ Review Cadence: [weekly]
+ Owner: [role/person]
+
+ User Confirmation:
+ Confirmed By: [user identifier]
+ Timestamp: [ISO 8601]
+ Acknowledgment: "I understand this decision is Category 4 (CATASTROPHIC reversal cost).
+ I have reviewed the exit plan, early warning signals, and alternatives.
+ I authorize this commitment."
+
+ Expiration: [date or condition for re-evaluation]
+ ────────────────────────────────────────
+ ```
+
+ **Artifact:** `commitment_` — the final gate for Category 4 decisions.
+
+ **CEI Component:** Commitment (weight 5.0)
+
+ ---
+
+ ### Step 6 — EARLY WARNING SIGNALS (if `require_early_warning` = true)
+
+ **NEW IN v2.0** — Observable signals that a decision is going wrong, defined BEFORE commitment.
+
+ ```
+ EARLY WARNING SIGNALS
+ ────────────────────────────────────────
+ For the chosen option, define signals that would indicate the decision is failing:
+
+ Signal 1: [Name]
+ Metric: [specific measurable metric — e.g., "p99 latency > 500ms"]
+ Threshold: [specific value — e.g., "> 500ms for 5 consecutive minutes"]
+ Detection: [how measured — e.g., "Datadog dashboard 'API Latency'"]
+ Lead Time: [how early this signal appears before catastrophic failure — e.g., "2 weeks"]
+ False Positive Rate: [estimated — e.g., "5%"]
+ Action: [specific response — e.g., "trigger rollback procedure Phase 1"]
+ Owner: [who responds]
+
+ Signal 2: [Name]
+ ...
+
+ Signal 3: [Name]
+ ...
+
+ Signal Validation:
+ Each signal must be:
+ - Observable (measurable without human judgment)
+ - Specific (threshold is a number, not "feels slow")
+ - Actionable (triggers a defined response)
+ - Early (appears before irreversible damage)
+ - Low noise (false positive rate < 20%)
+
+ Composite Early Warning Index:
+ EWI = Σ (Signal_Weight × Signal_Active) / Σ Signal_Weight
+ If EWI > 0.7 → ESCALATE (trigger review/rollback)
+ ────────────────────────────────────────
+ ```
+
+ **Artifact:** `early_warning_signals` with metrics, thresholds, detection, lead times, actions, and composite index.
+
+ **CEI Component:** Early Warning Signals (weight 3.0)
+
+ ---
+
+ ### 7 — METRICS: Compute and Output Depth Metrics
+
+ #### 7.1 Phase Activation (for ADS)
+
+ ```json
+ {
+ "phase": 5,
+ "skill": "threshold",
+ "artifact_completeness": 0.XX,
+ "gate_pass_rate": 0.XX,
+ "external_validity": 0.XX,
+ "human_eval": 0.XX,
+ "phase_activation": 0.XX
+ }
+ ```
+
+ #### 7.2 CEI Components
+
+ ```json
+ {
+ "cei_components": {
+ "threshold_classification": 2.0,
+ "depth_requirement": 1.0,
+ "termination_gates": 3.0,
+ "exit_plan": 4.0,
+ "reversal_cost_function": 4.0,
+ "commitment_": 5.0,
+ "early_warning_signals": 3.0,
+ "total_complexity_weight": 22.0,
+ "output_tokens": N,
+ "wall_time_seconds": T,
+ "cei": 0.XX
+ }
+ }
+ ```
+
+ #### 7.3 SI Components
+
+ ```json
+ {
+ "si_components": {
+ "c2_c3_count": 0,
+ "contrarian_viable": false,
+ "fatal_attacks": 0,
+ "boundary_violations": 0,
+ "assumption_reversals": 0,
+ "si_total": 0
+ }
+ }
+ ```
+
+ #### 7.4 Cognitive Traces
+
+ **Reversal Cost Function:**
+ ```json
+ {
+ "type": "reversal_cost_function",
+ "decision": "...",
+ "category": 3,
+ "function": "R(t) = C_fixed + C_variable(t) + C_opportunity(t) + C_risk(t)",
+ "parameters": {
+ "C_fixed": 10000,
+ "C_variable_daily": 500,
+ "C_opportunity_daily": 2000,
+ "C_risk_probability": 0.1,
+ "C_risk_impact": 50000
+ },
+ "values": {
+ "R(0)": 10000,
+ "R(30)": 85000,
+ "R(90)": 265000,
+ "R(365)": 1000000,
+ "R(inf)": 1500000
+ },
+ "blast_radius": "users",
+ "category": 3
+ }
+ ```
+
+ **Commitment :** (as defined in Step 5)
+
+ **Early Warning Signals:**
+ ```json
+ {
+ "type": "early_warning_signals",
+ "signals": [
+ {"name": "Latency Spike", "metric": "p99_latency", "threshold": 500, "unit": "ms",
+ "detection": "Datadog", "lead_time_days": 14, "fpr": 0.05, "action": "rollback_phase1"},
+ {"name": "Error Rate", "metric": "error_rate", "threshold": 0.01, "unit": "ratio",
+ "detection": "PagerDuty", "lead_time_days": 7, "fpr": 0.02, "action": "investigate"}
+ ],
+ "composite_ewi": 0.0,
+ "escalation_threshold": 0.7
+ }
+ ```
+
+ #### 7.5 Depth Contribution
+
+ ```json
+ {
+ "skill": "threshold",
+ "version": "2.0",
+ "metrics": {"ads_contribution": 0.XX, "cei": 0.XX, "si": 0, "ec": 0.XX},
+ "gates_verified": {"V1": true, "V2": true, "V3": true, "V4": true, "V5": true, "V6": true},
+ "limitations": ["..."]
+ }
+ ```
+
+ ---
+
+ ### 8 — GATES: Verify Before Delivery
+
+ **MANDATORY** — Verify these gates PASS (all categories as applicable):
+
+ | Gate | Check | Pass Condition |
+ |------|-------|----------------|
+ | **V1** | Problem Fidelity | Restatement captures user intent |
+ | **V2** | Alternative Coverage | ≥2/3 approaches with CIM ≥ 0.5 |
+ | **V3** | Assumption Exposure | C2/C3 assumptions named and rated |
+ | **V4** | Failure-Mode Analysis | Failure paths identified (NEGATIVE-SPACE) |
+ | **V5** | Reversibility Plan | Exit plan + R(t) written |
+ | **V6** | Decision Rationale | Specific rationale + EC ≥ 0.5 |
+ | **V7** | Early Warning Signals | Observable signals with thresholds defined |
+ | **V8** | Commitment | Category 4: + user confirmation |
+
+ **If any gate FAILS:** Return to relevant step and fix. Do not deliver.
+
+ ---
+
+ ### 9 — INTERFERENCE: Receive and Provide
+
+ **Receive from prior skills:**
+
+ | From Skill | Interference | Use |
+ |------------|--------------|-----|
+ | TEMPORAL | Regret scenarios | Inform reversal cost function |
+ | NEGATIVE-SPACE | Critical silences | Define early warning signals |
+ | PROVENANCE | EC score | Gate G6 threshold |
+ | DIVERGE | CIM score | Gate G2 threshold |
+ | ADVERSARY | Fatal attacks | Inform failure-mode analysis |
+
+ **Provide to later skills:**
+
+ | To Skill | Interference | Minimum ADS Gain |
+ |----------|--------------|------------------|
+ | CONDUCTOR | Final commitment verdict | +0.15 |
+ | META-LEARNING | Decision patterns for policy learning | +0.10 |
+
+ **Artifact:** `interference_log` (received and provided).
+
+ ---
+
## The Deeper Purpose
- This skill creates automatic depth-scaling. Trivial decisions get fast answers. Irreversible decisions get deep exploration. The gateway prevents the most expensive class of error: confident, fast, wrong, and permanent. Stopping is a decision — this skill ensures it's a considered one.
+ This skill creates automatic depth-scaling. Trivial decisions get fast answers. Irreversible decisions get deep exploration. **The gateway prevents the most expensive class of error: confident, fast, wrong, and permanent.** Now it quantifies reversal cost as a function, produces verifiable commitment s, and defines observable early warning signals. Stopping is a decision — this skill ensures it's a considered, measurable, and auditable one.
+ ---
+
+ ## MATHEMATICS COMPLIANCE
+
+ ### Phase Activation Output
+ This skill contributes to Phase 5. It outputs:
+ ```json
+ {
+ "phase": 5,
+ "skill": "threshold",
+ "artifact_completeness": 0.XX,
+ "gate_pass_rate": 0.XX,
+ "external_validity": 0.XX,
+ "human_eval": 0.XX,
+ "phase_activation": 0.XX
+ }
+ ```
+
+ ### CEI Components
+ - Artifacts produced: threshold_classification (2.0), depth_requirement (1.0), termination_gates (3.0), exit_plan (4.0), reversal_cost_function (4.0), commitment_ (5.0), early_warning_signals (3.0)
+ - Total complexity weight: 22.0
+
+ ### SI Components
+ - C2/C3 assumptions: 0
+ - Contrarian viable: false
+ - Fatal attacks: 0
+ - Boundary violations: 0
+ - Assumption reversals: 0
+
+ ### Cognitive Traces Produced
+ - [x] Reversal Cost Function
+ - [x] Commitment
+ - [x] Early Warning Signals
+ - [ ] Decision Landscape
+
+ ### Gates Verified
+ - [x] V1 [x] V2 [x] V3 [x] V4 [x] V5 [x] V6
+ - [x] V7 [x] V8 (Category 4)
+ - [ ] Human Eval [ ] Held-Out [ ] Ensemble
+
+ ### Required Interferences
+ - From TEMPORAL: Regret scenarios → reversal cost function
+ - From NEGATIVE-SPACE: Critical silences → early warning signals
+ - From PROVENANCE: EC score → Gate G6
+ - From DIVERGE: CIM score → Gate G2
+ - From ADVERSARY: Fatal attacks → Gate G4