git:20261110.0e87468 to git:20261110.5be8a6c

2 added, 2 removed. Audit A to A.

What this update changes in the checks

No check changed: every fixed check gives the same answer before and after this update.

A tripped check is a label, not a verdict: read the matched text and the lines below. This week's updates that newly trip a check.

---
name: prior-art-search
description: Systematic 7-step methodology for comprehensive patent prior art searches and patentability assessments using Google Patents (SerpApi) or BigQuery, CPC classification and research-paper search
tools: Bash, Read, Write
model: sonnet
---
# Prior Art Search Skill
Systematic 7-step methodology for comprehensive patent prior art searches and patentability assessments.
## When to Use
Invoke this skill when users ask to:
- Conduct prior art search for an invention
- Assess patentability of an idea
- Perform freedom-to-operate analysis
- Find blocking patents
- Research patent landscapes
- Prepare for patent filing
## What This Skill Does
Implements a professional 7-step prior art search methodology combining:
- Keyword searches across 100M+ patents (Google Patents via SerpApi, or BigQuery)
- Research papers before the priority date (`search_non_patent_literature`)
- CPC classification searches
- USPTO API searches
- Timeline analysis
- Patentability assessment
- IDS (Information Disclosure Statement) preparation
## The 7-Step Methodology
### Step 1: Invention Definition (2-3 min)
**Goal**: Extract key features and define innovation scope
**Process**:
1. Interview user about invention
2. Extract core technical elements
3. Identify novel features
4. List all components/steps
5. Define search scope
**Output**: Structured invention summary with key features
**Questions to Ask**:
- What problem does this solve?
- What are the key components/steps?
- What makes this different from existing solutions?
- What is the core innovation?
---
### Step 2: Keyword Strategy (2-3 min)
**Goal**: Develop comprehensive search keyword list
**Process**:
1. Primary keywords from invention
2. Synonyms and variations
3. Technical terminology
4. Industry-specific terms
5. Synonym sets to run as separate searches
**Query syntax (important):** the keyword search splits a query into terms and
requires **every term** to appear (AND), each matching the title, abstract, or
claims (results are ranked by relevance, title hits weighted highest). It does
**not** parse Boolean operators — `AND`/`OR`/parentheses are ignored. So:
- Use plain space-separated terms for the AND set: `blockchain authentication`.
- Wrap a phrase in double quotes to require it verbatim: `"distributed ledger"`.
- For OR / synonyms, run **separate searches** and merge the results — don't put
`OR` in one query.
**Output**: Keyword search strategy document
**Example**:
```
Primary: blockchain authentication
Synonyms: distributed ledger verification, cryptographic authentication
Technical: public key infrastructure, digital signature
Related: decentralized identity, trustless verification
Searches (run each separately, then merge/dedupe):
- blockchain authentication
- "distributed ledger" verification
- cryptographic authentication
- "public key infrastructure" signature
```
---
### Step 3: Broad Keyword Search (3-5 min)
**Goal**: Cast wide net to find relevant patents
**Which patent search to use:** call `check_google_patents_status` first. If it is ready (the free SerpApi key from the README's Quick Start, Step 3), run every keyword search with `search_patents_google`. If not, use `search_patents_bigquery` only when `check_bigquery_status` says BigQuery is configured. If neither is set up, stop and tell the user patent search needs one free key (README Quick Start, Step 3) rather than reporting "no prior art". CPC searches (`search_patents_by_cpc_bigquery`) need BigQuery; without it, say in the report that the CPC step was done as keyword searches only.
**Process**:
1. Run keyword searches (`search_patents_google`, or `search_patents_bigquery` as above)
2. Review top 20-30 results per query
3. Identify most relevant patents
4. Refine keyword strategy based on results
5. Document relevant patents found
**Tool calls** (MCP tools, not Python imports):
```
search_patents_google(query="blockchain authentication", limit=30, start_year=2015)
# fallback when SerpApi isn't set up but BigQuery is:
search_patents_bigquery(query="blockchain authentication", limit=30, country="US", start_year=2015)
# papers count as prior art too; set published_before to the priority date:
search_non_patent_literature(query="blockchain authentication", published_before="2024-01-15")
```
**Output**: List of 10-20 potentially relevant patents
---
### Step 4: CPC Code Identification (2-3 min)
**Goal**: Find relevant classification codes
**Process**:
1. Extract CPC codes from relevant patents found in Step 3
2. Analyze CPC code descriptions
3. Identify primary classification areas
4. Select 3-5 most relevant CPC codes
5. Note CPC hierarchies
**Common CPC Categories**:
- **G06F**: Computing/data processing
- **H04L**: Digital communication/networks
- **G06Q**: Business methods
- **H04W**: Wireless communication
- **G06N**: AI/neural networks
- **G06T**: Image processing
**Output**: List of relevant CPC codes with descriptions
---
### Step 5: Deep CPC Search (5-10 min)
**Goal**: Comprehensive search within classifications
**Process**:
1. Search each CPC code identified
2. Review 50-100 patents per CPC code
3. Read abstracts and claims of top matches
4. Document closest prior art
5. Note key differences from invention
**Tool call** (needs BigQuery; without it, run `search_patents_google` with keywords from the CPC titles and note "CPC step keyword-only" in the report):
```
search_patents_by_cpc_bigquery(cpc_code="G06F21/", limit=100, country="US")
```
**Output**: Comprehensive list of potentially blocking patents
---
### Step 6: Timeline Analysis (2-3 min)
**Goal**: Understand technology evolution
**Process**:
1. Filter results by date ranges
2. Identify filing trends over time
3. Find recent developments (last 2 years)
4. Check priority dates
5. Note technology progression
**Tool calls** (whichever patent search is set up, as in Step 3):
```
search_patents_google(query=QUERY, start_year=2022, end_year=2024)
search_patents_google(query=QUERY, start_year=2015, end_year=2021)
```
**Output**: Timeline showing technology development
---
### Step 7: Patentability Report (5-10 min)
**Goal**: Professional assessment and recommendations
**Process**:
1. Analyze top 10 closest prior art
2. Assess novelty (35 USC 102)
3. Assess non-obviousness (35 USC 103)
4. Rank prior art by relevance
5. Provide claim strategy recommendations
6. Generate IDS list
**Output**: Comprehensive patentability report
---
## Report Format
```markdown
# PRIOR ART SEARCH REPORT
## Executive Summary
- Invention: [Brief description]
- Search Date: [Date]
- Searcher: Claude Patent Creator
- Databases: whichever answered: Google Patents (SerpApi) or BigQuery, plus the paper sources `search_non_patent_literature` reports as searched
- Time Period: [Year range]
## Patentability Assessment
### Novelty (35 USC 102)
[Assessment of whether invention is novel]
Score: [High/Medium/Low]
Analysis:
- No exact matches found
- Closest prior art: US10123456
- Key differences: [List]
### Non-Obviousness (35 USC 103)
[Assessment of whether invention is non-obvious]
Score: [High/Medium/Low]
Analysis:
- Combinations considered: [List]
- Motivation to combine: [Analysis]
- Unexpected results: [If any]
## Top 10 Most Relevant Prior Art
### 1. US10123456B2 - [Title] (95% Relevance)
**Assignee**: Example Corp
**Filed**: 2018-03-15
**Granted**: 2019-09-30
**CPC**: G06F21/31, H04L29/06
**Summary**: [Brief abstract]
**Similarities**:
- Uses blockchain for authentication
- Employs public key cryptography
- Distributed verification
**Differences**:
- Does not use [novel feature 1]
- Lacks [novel feature 2]
- Different approach to [aspect]
**Relevance**: High - core technology overlap
---
[Continue for top 10 patents...]
## Search Methodology
### Keywords Used
- Primary: blockchain, authentication, distributed ledger
- Synonyms: cryptographic verification, decentralized identity
- Technical: public key infrastructure, digital signature
### CPC Codes Searched
- G06F21/31 (Authentication)
- H04L29/06 (Security arrangements)
- G06Q20/40 (Payment authentication)
### Databases
- Google BigQuery: 247 results reviewed
- USPTO API: 89 results reviewed
- Total patents analyzed: 336
- Relevant patents identified: 47
- Top prior art selected: 10
## Claim Strategy Recommendations
### Recommended Approach
1. **Focus on novel aspects**: [Specific features]
2. **Claim breadth**: Start broad, add dependent claims
3. **Avoid prior art**: Distinguish from US10123456 by [...]
### Suggested Independent Claim Language
```
A system for [invention], comprising:
[novel element 1];
[novel element 2];
wherein [novel relationship/function]
```
### Dependent Claim Opportunities
- Specific implementations of [feature]
- Combinations with [technology]
- Variations in [parameter/configuration]
## IDS (Information Disclosure Statement) List
Patents to be disclosed to USPTO:
1. US10123456B2 - [Title]
2. US10234567A1 - [Title]
3. US10345678B1 - [Title]
4. US10456789A1 - [Title]
5. US10567890B2 - [Title]
6. EP3123456A1 - [Title]
7. WO2019/123456 - [Title]
8. US2020/0123456A1 - [Title]
9. US10678901B2 - [Title]
10. US10789012A1 - [Title]
## Conclusion
**Patentability**: [High/Medium/Low]
**Rationale**:
[Summary of why invention is or is not patentable]
**Recommended Next Steps**:
1. [Action item 1]
2. [Action item 2]
3. [Action item 3]
```
## Integration Points
This skill integrates with:
- - **BigQuery Patent Search** skill (Step 3, 5, 6)
+ - **Patent Search** skill (Steps 3, 5, 6); **BigQuery Patent Search** only when configured
- **MPEP Search** skill (For legal guidance)
- **Patent Claims Analyzer** (For claim drafting)
## Required Data Access
- - Google Cloud BigQuery (100M+ patents)
+ - Google Patents through SerpApi (default), or Google Cloud BigQuery (optional)
- USPTO API (optional, for additional coverage)
- Internet access for patent retrieval
## Estimated Time
- **Quick Search** (Steps 1-3): 10-15 minutes
- **Thorough Search** (Steps 1-6): 25-35 minutes
- **Complete Report** (All 7 steps): 40-60 minutes
## Tools Available
- **Bash**: To run Python searches
- **Write**: To save report and findings
- **Read**: To load invention descriptions
- **Grep**: To search through results