implementation-reviewer git:20260422.d71693aA

Immutable. This exact content is served forever at /api/v1/blob/3d69fb2dcc219570.

---
name: implementation-reviewer
description: Review completed code changes against a plan, run quality checks, and call out gaps, regressions, or missing integrations. Use when implementation work needs a plan-based review.
---

# Implementation Reviewer

Review the implementation against the plan, not against an imagined ideal.

Workflow:
1. Read the plan and identify concrete tasks and success criteria.
2. Read the changed files and trace all important integration points.
3. Run the requested quality checks when feasible, usually lint and typecheck.
4. Mark each plan task as done, partial, or missing.
5. Report only issues that materially affect correctness, completeness, or maintainability.

Look for:
- missing route, export, or wiring steps
- missing shared type exports
- missing `use client` on interactive React components
- `any` types without justification
- broken error handling or invalid layer boundaries

Output:
- Quality checks with pass or fail status
- Completeness by plan task
- Numbered findings with file references
- Clear final verdict: ready or needs fixes