final-acceptance ยท diff
git:20260906.8c3fe5c to git:20260906.338b084
22 added, 3 removed. Audit A to A.
---
name: final-acceptance
description: Judge the integrated production game against prompt, play, presentation, asset, and performance evidence.
disable-model-invocation: true
---
Require: fixed integrated `artifact:` identity, accepted core baseline,
production asset manifests, immutable traceability and [final rubric](../../references/final-rubric.md),
complete capture matrix, every required play account, qualified performance
cells, QA result, and parent frame journal.
Read the journal, freeze the evidence index, and judge the joined candidate:
tickets.py judge <run> --standard threejs-browser-game --standard browser-game-3d-asset --standard browser-game-interface --standard browser-game-playtest --parent <frame> --artifacts <integrated-artifact> --goal-file <final-judge-goal> --isolation required
The final gate requires a browser-served production build that starts without
developer tools, documented controls, every prompt-derived mechanic and state,
approved production assets with closed provenance, no blocking console,
network, or load errors, adaptive play from at least two independent
contexts, complete boot/entry/combat/progression/boss or terminal/win-loss/
restart/re-entry captures, and every declared performance cell. It scores
presentation, play, prompt fidelity, and performance only from indexed
evidence. Static surfaces report counts without an FPS claim.
For a blocking verdict, relay its complete `findings:` line to one bounded
- repair and repeat affected QA, play, capture, and judgment:
+ repair and repeat affected QA, play, capture, and judgment. A quality-cycle
+ batch has a local bound of two repair/re-judge rounds. If the first re-judge
+ still blocks, the parent opens the one automatic successor round with the
+ complete append-only complaint ledger, fixed acceptance criteria, and the
+ best artifact identity; it does not ask permission for this already-authorized
+ successor. A second blocked re-judge ends that batch and routes the recorded
+ disposition through the parent:
+ - `fix` opens the next bounded repair with only accepted complaints and their
+ regression checks;
+ - `redesign` returns to discovery with a new concept revision and named
+ invalidations; and
+ - `unverified` opens missing-evidence acquisition or a capable execution
+ context, preserving narrower evidence until it is observed.
+
+ Every route appends its findings, cause, evidence, expected improvement, and
+ exact resume state before continuing or stopping.
+
tickets.py do <run> --standard threejs-browser-game --parent <frame> --goal-file <final-repair-goal> --isolation required
tickets.py judge <run> --standard threejs-browser-game --standard browser-game-3d-asset --standard browser-game-interface --standard browser-game-playtest --parent <frame> --artifacts <repaired-artifact> --goal-file <final-rejudge-goal> --isolation required
Keep complaint IDs append-only, diagnose stagnation or oscillation with a
changed strategy, and preserve the best fixed revision plus unresolved
findings and resume state at a real external or budget limit. A performance
miss repeats the identical cell after one causal repair. An evidence loss,
ambiguous canvas attribution, trace mismatch, or gameplay-changing asset is
`unverified` until its boundary is repaired.
Never average contradictory evidence, waive a hard gate for attractive art,
- call scripted input actual play, or claim a final pass without the outside
- probe's joined revision.
+ or call scripted input actual play. The independent final gate may pass its
+ fixed source before the outside probe runs; public workflow completion may
+ claim final acceptance only after the outside probe observes that joined
+ revision. Keep the pending outside status, fixed identities, and gate evidence
+ visible between those two checks.
Return: completed ticket carrying `artifact:` for the best or accepted final
revision, final gate-verdict and evidence-index identities, complaint ledger,
outside-probe requirement, disposition, gaps, and exact resume state.