final-acceptance ยท diff
git:20260906.338b084 to git:20260906.8f54cb6
15 added, 17 removed. Audit A to A.
---
name: final-acceptance
description: Judge the integrated production game against prompt, play, presentation, asset, and performance evidence.
disable-model-invocation: true
---
Require: fixed integrated `artifact:` identity, accepted core baseline,
production asset manifests, immutable traceability and [final rubric](../../references/final-rubric.md),
complete capture matrix, every required play account, qualified performance
cells, QA result, and parent frame journal.
Read the journal, freeze the evidence index, and judge the joined candidate:
tickets.py judge <run> --standard threejs-browser-game --standard browser-game-3d-asset --standard browser-game-interface --standard browser-game-playtest --parent <frame> --artifacts <integrated-artifact> --goal-file <final-judge-goal> --isolation required
- The final gate requires a browser-served production build that starts without
- developer tools, documented controls, every prompt-derived mechanic and state,
- approved production assets with closed provenance, no blocking console,
- network, or load errors, adaptive play from at least two independent
- contexts, complete boot/entry/combat/progression/boss or terminal/win-loss/
- restart/re-entry captures, and every declared performance cell. It scores
+ The final gate requires a browser-served production build without developer
+ tools, documented controls, every prompt-derived mechanic and state, approved
+ assets with closed provenance, no blocking console, network, or load errors,
+ adaptive play from at least two independent contexts, complete
+ boot/entry/combat/progression/boss or terminal/win-loss/restart/re-entry
+ captures, and every declared performance cell. It scores
presentation, play, prompt fidelity, and performance only from indexed
evidence. Static surfaces report counts without an FPS claim.
For a blocking verdict, relay its complete `findings:` line to one bounded
- repair and repeat affected QA, play, capture, and judgment. A quality-cycle
- batch has a local bound of two repair/re-judge rounds. If the first re-judge
- still blocks, the parent opens the one automatic successor round with the
- complete append-only complaint ledger, fixed acceptance criteria, and the
- best artifact identity; it does not ask permission for this already-authorized
- successor. A second blocked re-judge ends that batch and routes the recorded
- disposition through the parent:
+ repair and repeat affected QA, play, capture, and judgment. A batch permits
+ two repair/re-judge rounds. If re-judge still blocks, the parent opens one
+ automatic successor with the complete append-only complaint ledger, fixed
+ criteria, and best artifact identity; permission is unnecessary. A second
+ blocked re-judge ends the batch and routes its disposition through the parent:
- `fix` opens the next bounded repair with only accepted complaints and their
regression checks;
- `redesign` returns to discovery with a new concept revision and named
invalidations; and
- `unverified` opens missing-evidence acquisition or a capable execution
context, preserving narrower evidence until it is observed.
Every route appends its findings, cause, evidence, expected improvement, and
exact resume state before continuing or stopping.
tickets.py do <run> --standard threejs-browser-game --parent <frame> --goal-file <final-repair-goal> --isolation required
tickets.py judge <run> --standard threejs-browser-game --standard browser-game-3d-asset --standard browser-game-interface --standard browser-game-playtest --parent <frame> --artifacts <repaired-artifact> --goal-file <final-rejudge-goal> --isolation required
- Keep complaint IDs append-only, diagnose stagnation or oscillation with a
- changed strategy, and preserve the best fixed revision plus unresolved
- findings and resume state at a real external or budget limit. A performance
- miss repeats the identical cell after one causal repair. An evidence loss,
+ Keep complaint IDs append-only; diagnose stagnation or oscillation with a
+ changed strategy; preserve the best fixed revision, unresolved findings, and
+ resume state at an external or budget limit. A performance miss repeats the
+ identical cell after one causal repair. An evidence loss,
ambiguous canvas attribution, trace mismatch, or gameplay-changing asset is
`unverified` until its boundary is repaired.
Never average contradictory evidence, waive a hard gate for attractive art,
or call scripted input actual play. The independent final gate may pass its
fixed source before the outside probe runs; public workflow completion may
claim final acceptance only after the outside probe observes that joined
revision. Keep the pending outside status, fixed identities, and gate evidence
visible between those two checks.
Return: completed ticket carrying `artifact:` for the best or accepted final
revision, final gate-verdict and evidence-index identities, complaint ledger,
outside-probe requirement, disposition, gaps, and exact resume state.