28-community-building-global · diff
v1.0.0 to v1.0.1
2 added, 2 removed. Audit A to A.
---
name: 28-community-building-global
- description: "Community building for global personal brand — Skool, Mighty Networks, Discord, Circle, Slack. 3-layer blueprint (Public/Member/Inner). 7-day onboarding. Engagement rituals. Moderation playbook. Activation metrics. Trigger: 'community building', 'Skool community', 'Mighty Networks', 'Discord community', 'paid community', 'mastermind community'."
+ description: "Use when a PERSONAL brand needs its OWN community — Skool, Mighty Networks, Discord, Circle, or Slack: a three-layer public, member, and inner-circle blueprint, seven-day onboarding, engagement rituals, a moderation playbook, and activation metrics. Trigger on 'build a community', 'Skool community', 'Mighty Networks setup', 'Discord for my audience', 'paid community', 'my group is dead and nobody posts'. Also use when the user has members and no reason for them to come back. Not for — posting inside communities you do NOT own, see `38-community-seeding-global`; pricing and packaging the membership, see `27-personal-brand-monetize-global`; referral loops, see `18-referral-program-global`."
metadata:
- version: 1.0.0
+ version: 1.0.1
category: operations
license: MIT
triggers:
- "community building"
- "Skool community"
- "Mighty Networks"
- "Discord community"
- "paid community"
- "mastermind community"
related:
- 22-personal-brand-context-global
- 27-personal-brand-monetize-global
- 14-email-marketing-global
---
# Community Building — Global Personal Brand
> Audience = people who follow you. **Community = people who talk to each other** around you. The core difference: audience scales by count, community scales by connection. This skill builds community as a **moat** for your personal brand — uncopyable.
---
## 1. Newbie section
### Audience vs Community — the critical distinction
| Criterion | Audience | Community |
|-----------|----------|-----------|
| Relationship | 1-many (you -> follower) | many-many (member <-> member) |
| Owner | You | You + members co-create |
| Scale | Works at tens of thousands | Capped ~150-1000 chat |
| Monetization | Course, brand deal | Membership, mastermind |
| Defensibility | Easy to copy | Hard to copy (network effect) |
### When to start a community
DO NOT start too early. Wait for 3 conditions:
1. **Audience >2,000 quality followers** — enough to seed an initial community of 50-100
2. **At least 1 successful product/offer** — community is a retention moat, NOT your first sales channel
3. **Time available >5 hrs/week for 6 months** — community needs the host present daily
### 5 common mistakes building community
1. **Build the group then walk away** — 1 month later it's dead, members spam ads -> close
2. **1,000 members but 90% lurkers** — only 50-100 active -> low ROI
3. **Spam selling inside the group** — admin posts offers daily -> trust erodes -> members leave
4. **No clear rules** — toxic members run wild -> good members leave -> only toxic stays
5. **Wrong platform** — picking Discord for a 50+ professional audience -> 80% drop out at onboarding
### Real time investment
- **Initial setup**: 2-4 weeks (pick platform, write rules, onboard 50 founding members)
- **Daily check-in**: 30-60 min/day in months 1-3
- **Weekly events**: 1-2 hrs/week (livestream, AMA, workshop)
- **Total**: 8-15 hrs/week in the first 6 months, then delegate to a moderator team
---
## 2. Information collection
Ask up to 4 questions:
1. **Current audience size and main platform?** Total followers + main channel (drives platform choice)
2. **Member persona?** Young / mid-career / senior, B2B/B2C, paid/free? (Decides platform and monetization)
3. **Community goal?** Free retention community / Paid community as primary income / High-end mastermind (3 different paths)
4. **Resources?** Solo or team? Budget for platform/moderators? (Drives scale and platform choice)
---
## 3. Platform Comparison (Global) 2026
| Platform | Cost | UX | Max members | Monetization | Pros | Cons | Best for | Setup time |
|----------|------|----|--------------|---------------|------|------|----------|-----------|
| **Skool** | $99/mo base | 9/10 | Unlimited (paid plan) | Paid course + community combo, $9-499/mo/member | All-in-one (course + community + classroom), gamification leaderboard | English-first, payment via Stripe only | Coach/creator with course + community | 2-4 weeks |
| **Mighty Networks** | $39-179/mo | 8/10 | Unlimited | Subscription, course, event tickets | Customizable, native course, branded mobile app | Steep learning curve, US/EU payment focus | Multi-product personal brand | 3-5 weeks |
| **Discord** | Free | 7/10 | 500K | Premium Memberships ($5-100/mo), Boosts | Voice channels + threads + role permissions, Gen Z native | Setup complex, weaker for non-tech audiences | Gen Z gaming/crypto/dev/creative | 2-3 weeks |
| **Circle** | $49-199/mo | 9/10 | Unlimited | Memberships, paid events, courses | Polished UI, threads, native mobile app | Pricier than Skool, no leaderboard out-of-box | Professional creators, B2B coaches | 2-3 weeks |
| **Slack Communities** | Free / paid | 8/10 | 10K active | Paid Slack workspace, sponsorship | Familiar to professionals, message threading | DMs hidden after free quota, no native course | B2B professional communities | 1-2 weeks |
| **Facebook Group** | Free | 9/10 | Unlimited | Subscription Group ($5-30/mo), member-only post | Reach existing FB audience, search, threaded | Reach declining, FB algorithm dependent, spam-prone | Mass audience, beginner communities | 1 week |
### Quick decision tree
```mermaid
graph TD
A[Member persona?] --> B{Age + niche}
B -->|Gen Z, tech/crypto/gaming| C[Discord]
B -->|Professional B2B| D{Free or Paid?}
B -->|Coach with course| E[Skool or Mighty Networks]
B -->|Mass audience| F[Facebook Group]
D -->|Free community| G[Slack or FB Group]
D -->|Paid premium| H{Need course?}
H -->|Yes| I[Skool or Mighty Networks]
H -->|No| J[Circle or Slack paid]
```
---
## 4. Community Blueprint — 3 Layers
> 3 layers = different access levels by depth of engagement. Each layer has a different content type and goal.
### Layer 1: Public (open content, free, mass)
- **Goal**: Awareness — convert outsider to follower
- **Channels**: SEO blog, social media (LinkedIn / Twitter/X / TikTok / YouTube), podcast
- **Content**: Long-form essays, how-to videos, podcast interviews, public case studies
- **Volume**: 5-7 posts/week
- **Metric**: Reach, follows, traffic
- **Direct monetization**: 0 (only contributes to brand awareness)
### Layer 2: Member (free signup, warm)
- **Goal**: Trust — convert follower to "member" with direct contact
- **Channels**: Email newsletter, free Slack/FB Group/Discord/Skool free tier
- **Content**: Weekly deep newsletter, monthly AMA, quarterly free workshop
- **Volume**: 1-3 pieces/week
- **Metric**: Email open rate (>25%), member active rate (>30%)
- **Direct monetization**: Affiliate, soft offers; 5-10% conversion to paid
### Layer 3: Inner (paid, hot)
- **Goal**: Activation — convert trust to revenue + deeper connection
- **Channels**: Paid community (Skool / Mighty / Circle), 1:1 mastermind, retreats
- **Content**: Weekly office hours, monthly mastermind, quarterly retreat, exclusive course
- **Volume**: 1-2 high-touch events/week
- **Metric**: Retention >70% at 6 months, NPS >50
- **Direct monetization**: 100% — primary revenue source
### Example: Coach with 5,000 LinkedIn followers
- Public: 5 LinkedIn posts/week + 1 podcast/month -> 1,000 reach/post avg
- Member: 1,500 newsletter subs + 800-member free Slack -> monthly AMA
- Inner: 80-member Skool community at $99/mo = **$7,920/mo MRR**
---
## 5. Onboarding Flow — 7 Days
> These 7 days decide stay vs leave. >50% of communities die from poor onboarding.
### Day 0 (before joining)
- Welcome page with personal 60s welcome video (you, NOT generic)
- Form to capture: name, niche, this month's goal
- 1 calendar link (weekly Zoom onboarding call)
### Day 1
- **Auto DM/email welcome**: introduces rules + 3 things to do now (post intro, read pinned post, fill profile)
- **Pinned intro post**: asks new members to introduce themselves (template: name, niche, goal, one question)
- **Founder responds**: you MUST reply 100% to intros in the first 24h (builds strong trust)
### Day 2-3
- **Quick first win**: send free PDF checklist / template (so members feel "I already received value")
- **Tag a buddy**: tag 2-3 active veteran members to greet new ones (reduces awkwardness)
### Day 4-5
- **Invite to event**: livestream / AMA next week (creates a reason to return)
- **Open question**: post a discussion-sparker, easy for new members to engage
### Day 6
- **Soft pitch Layer 3**: introduce paid tier (NOT hard sell, just "there's a deeper layer if you need it")
- **Short survey**: 3 questions (how is the community feeling, what's missing, which content do you like most)
### Day 7
- **Collective welcome call** (10-30 new members from the same week): 30 min, you introduce the community + Q&A
- After the call: 30-50% of new members engage strongly the following week
### Onboarding metrics target
- **Day 7 retention**: >70% (still active after 1 week)
- **Day 30 retention**: >50%
- **First post within 7 days**: >40% of new members
---
## 6. Engagement Rituals (weekly + monthly cadence)
> Ritual = an event repeating on a schedule. NO ritual = community dies in 3 months.
### Weekly cadence
| Day | Ritual | Owner | Time |
|-----|--------|-------|------|
| Mon | "Monday Goals" — members share their week's goal | Members post, you react | 5 min |
| Tue | Founder long-form post (lesson/insight) | You write | 30 min |
| Wed | "Wins Wednesday" — members share recent wins | Members post | 5 min |
| Thu | AMA / Office hours 30 min | You livestream | 30 min |
| Fri | "Friday Wrap" — week recap, top contributor | You post | 15 min |
| Sun | Weekly newsletter (community digest) | You send | 30 min |
### Monthly cadence
- **Week 1**: Workshop/training ~60 min (you teach a specific topic)
- **Week 2**: Member spotlight (showcase 1 member with strong progress)
- **Week 3**: Networking event (Zoom hangout, breakout rooms)
- **Week 4**: Retro + planning (member feedback, you share roadmap)
### Quarterly
- 1 retreat / mastermind day (offline best — popular international destinations: Bali, Lisbon, Mexico City, Austin)
- Lifetime event creates very strong bonds, retention >85% post-retreat
### Engagement metric targets (global) 2026
| Metric | Poor | Average | Good | Excellent |
|--------|------|---------|------|-----------|
| DAU/MAU | <10% | 10-25% | 25-40% | >40% |
| Posts per active member/week | <0.5 | 0.5-1.5 | 1.5-3 | >3 |
| Retention at 6 months | <40% | 40-60% | 60-75% | >75% |
| NPS | <30 | 30-50 | 50-70 | >70 |
---
## 7. Moderation Playbook
> No moderation = toxic community. 5 cardinal rules.
### 5 core rules (pinned, members agree on join)
1. **No spam selling/affiliate links** in main feed — except in pinned "Self-Promo Friday" thread
2. **No personal attacks** — disagreeing on ideas is fine, attacking people is not
3. **No NSFW / political / religious flame content**
4. **No sharing paid course material** of others publicly
5. **Introduce yourself before posting questions** — new members must intro before asking
### 3-step escalation
- **Step 1 — Warning**: first violation, mod DMs privately, removes post (NO public shaming)
- **Step 2 — 7-day mute**: second violation, member can't post for 7 days
- **Step 3 — Permanent ban**: third violation or serious offense (toxic, scam) -> ban + announce in group "a member violated rules and has been removed"
### Insta-ban policy (no warning)
- Spam scams (claiming "$100K/month no-work" schemes)
- Toxic doxxing (leaking other members' personal info)
- Selling competitors' products directly
- Bots/fake accounts
### Mod team setup at >300 members
- 1 lead mod (paid, $200-500/mo equivalent)
- 2-3 volunteer mods (highly engaged veterans, free + access to Layer 3)
- Mod meeting bi-weekly, 30 min
---
## 8. Activation Metrics + Anti-patterns
### 8.1 Health metrics tracking
Weekly tracker (Notion / Sheet dashboard):
| Metric | Formula | Target |
|--------|---------|--------|
| Total members | Headcount | Growth 5-15%/month |
| DAU | Active 1 day | 25-40% of MAU |
| MAU | Active 30 days | >50% of total |
| Posts/week | Total posts (members + admin) | 30+ posts/week per 100 members |
| Reply rate | Questions answered within 24h | >80% |
| 6-month retention | Members active at 6 months | >60% |
| NPS | Quarterly survey | >50 |
### 8.2 Activation events (signals a member is "active")
A member counts as "active" if they have done one of:
1. Posted a meaningful question/comment (>20 chars)
2. Attended a live event for >50% of the duration
3. Replied to someone else's post with their own perspective
4. DMed founder/mod with a specific question
### 8.3 Anti-patterns — 7 things NOT to do
1. **Spam selling** — admin posts offers 5x/day -> trust dies -> members leave
2. **High follower count, no engagement** — 5,000 members, 50 active -> meaningless
3. **Sales lasso** — admin tags every question into "you can solve that with my course" -> toxic
4. **No moderation** — 3 months later it's a billboard for crypto/MLM/forex spam
5. **Too many sub-region groups** — splits community -> each group of 100 anemic
6. **Public member ranks creating comparison** — leaderboard drama, low-rank members silently leave
7. **Founder vanishes for 2 weeks** — community depends on founder personality, absence = death
### 8.4 KPI rollup — first 6-12 months
| Milestone | Time | Target |
|-----------|------|--------|
| MVP launch | Weeks 1-4 | 50 founding members, retention >80% at 30 days |
| Healthy core | Months 2-3 | 200 members, DAU/MAU >25%, 1 ritual running smoothly |
| Scale | Months 4-6 | 500 members, mod team set up, paid tier launched |
| Self-sustaining | Months 7-12 | 1,000+ members, mods handle 70% of tasks, retention >65% |
---
## 9. Quality checklist
- [ ] Audience >2,000 followers before starting community
- [ ] At least 1 successful product/offer in market
- [ ] Platform fits audience persona (NOT chosen for fanciness)
- [ ] 5 clear rules + members sign agreement on join
- [ ] 7-day onboarding flow with automation (DM/email + pinned post)
- [ ] Weekly rituals set up (>=3 repeating rituals)
- [ ] Founder present in months 1-3 (>5 hrs/week)
- [ ] Mod team in place when members >300
- [ ] Tracking dashboard: DAU/MAU/retention/NPS
- [ ] Avoiding the 7 anti-patterns (spam, sales lasso, founder vanish)
---
*Skill 28 (Global) | v1.0.0*