paperlab-multireviewer-simulation git:20260919.77c34a0A

Immutable. This exact content is served forever at /api/v1/blob/dcc1d70179a71f81.

---
name: paperlab-multireviewer-simulation
description: |
  Run a simulated multi-reviewer critique of PaperLab manuscripts and books,
  covering novelty, methods, evidence, reproducibility, figures, and journal fit.
last_verified: "2026-09-18"
---

# PaperLab Multi-Reviewer Simulation

## When to Use

USE WHEN: preparing a manuscript, revision, or book release for serious external
review.

## Reviewer Roles

- handling editor,
- thermodynamics or process-simulation expert,
- numerical methods reviewer,
- reproducibility reviewer,
- application/domain reviewer,
- figure and table reviewer.

## Rubric

Score 1 to 5 for:

- novelty,
- evidence strength,
- method clarity,
- statistical validity,
- reproducibility,
- limitations disclosure,
- figure narrative,
- journal or publisher fit.

## Output Pattern

```markdown
## Reviewer 2: Numerical Methods

Major comments:
- ...

Minor comments:
- ...

Decision tendency: major revision
```

## Pass Criteria

- All blocker comments map to fixable evidence or prose actions.
- Editorial risk is explicit.
- The recommended decision is justified by the manuscript, not by taste alone.

## Safety Rules

- Do not fabricate external peer-review outcomes.
- Keep review comments anchored to manuscript sections and artifacts.
- Separate required fixes from optional polish.