git:20261006.bac0606 to git:20261110.5be8a6c

21 added, 24 removed. Audit A to A.

What this update changes in the checks

No check changed: every fixed check gives the same answer before and after this update.

A tripped check is a label, not a verdict: read the matched text and the lines below. This week's updates that newly trip a check.

---
name: patent-claims-analyzer
description: Automated analysis of patent claims for USPTO compliance with 35 USC 112(b) requirements - antecedent basis, definiteness, claim structure
tools: Bash, Read, Write
model: sonnet
---
# Patent Claims Analyzer Skill
+ Antecedent checking is disabled by default. Report it as skipped unless `checks_run` includes `antecedent_basis`; retain the reason in `checks_skipped`. Enabling `PATENT_ENABLE_ANTECEDENT_CHECK=1` requires a server restart. Even when enabled, this is a low-confidence pattern check requiring manual review.
+
Automated analysis of patent claims for USPTO compliance with 35 USC 112(b) requirements.
## When to Use
Invoke this skill when users ask to:
- Review patent claims for definiteness
- Check antecedent basis in claims
- Analyze claim structure
- Find claim drafting issues
- Validate claims before filing
- Fix USPTO office action issues related to claims
## What This Skill Does
Performs comprehensive automated analysis:
- 1. **Antecedent Basis Checking**:
+ 1. **Antecedent Basis Checking (opt-in)**:
- Finds terms used without prior introduction
- Detects missing "a/an" before first use
- Identifies improper "said/the" before first use
- Tracks term references across claims
2. **Definiteness Analysis** (35 USC 112(b)):
- Identifies subjective/indefinite terms
- Detects relative terms without reference
- Finds ambiguous claim language
- Checks for clear claim boundaries
3. **Claim Structure Validation**:
- Parses independent vs. dependent claims
- Validates claim dependencies
- Checks claim numbering
- Identifies claim type (method, system, etc.)
4. **Issue Categorization**:
- **Critical**: Must fix before filing
- **Important**: May cause rejection
- **Minor**: Best practice improvements
## Required Data
This skill uses the automated claims analyzer from:
- **Location**: `${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/python\claims_analyzer.py`
+ **Location**: `${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/mcp_server/claims_analyzer.py` (plugin source; the pip-installed module is `mcp_server.claims_analyzer`)
## How to Use
When this skill is invoked:
1. **Load the claims analyzer**:
```python
import os
import sys
sys.path.insert(0, os.environ.get('CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT', '.'))
from mcp_server.claims_analyzer import ClaimsAnalyzer
analyzer = ClaimsAnalyzer()
```
2. **Analyze claims**:
```python
claims_text = """
1. A system comprising:
a processor;
a memory; and
said processor configured to...
"""
results = analyzer.analyze_claims(claims_text)
```
3. **Present analysis**:
- Show compliance score (0-100)
- List issues by severity (critical, important, minor)
- Provide MPEP citations for each issue
- Suggest specific fixes
## Analysis Output Structure
```python
+ # Issue objects in results["issues"] (illustrative values):
{
- "claim_count": 20,
- "independent_count": 3,
- "dependent_count": 17,
- "compliance_score": 85, # 0-100
- "total_issues": 12,
- "critical_issues": 2,
- "important_issues": 7,
- "minor_issues": 3,
- "issues": [
- {
- "category": "antecedent_basis",
- "severity": "critical",
- "claim_number": 1,
- "term": "said processor",
- "description": "Term 'processor' used with 'said' before first introduction",
- "mpep_cite": "MPEP 2173.05(e)",
- "suggestion": "Change 'said processor' to 'the processor' or introduce with 'a processor' first"
- },
- # ... more issues
- ]
+ "severity": "IMPORTANT", # CRITICAL, IMPORTANT, MINOR, or WARNING
+ "type": "definiteness",
+ "claim": 1,
+ "location": "body",
+ "term": "approximately",
+ "problem": "Potentially unclear term; review in context",
+ "fix": "Consider an objective criterion where needed",
+ "mpep": "MPEP 2173.05(b)",
+ "confidence": "MEDIUM"
}
```
+ The report also includes `claim_count`, `independent_count`, `dependent_count`,
+ `compliance_score`, issue counts, `issues_by_type`, and `summary`.
+ US reports also include `checks_run`, `checks_skipped`, and `compliance_score_scope`.
+
+
## Common Issues Detected
- 1. **Antecedent Basis Errors**:
+ 1. **Antecedent Basis Errors (only when enabled)**:
- Using "said/the" before "a/an" introduction
- Terms appearing in dependent claims not in parent
- Missing antecedent in claim body
2. **Definiteness Issues**:
- Subjective terms: "substantially", "about", "approximately"
- Relative terms: "large", "small", "thin"
- Ambiguous language: "and/or", "optionally"
3. **Structure Issues**:
- - Means-plus-function without adequate structure
+ - Means-plus-function and corresponding specification structure require separate manual review; the analyzer does not check them
- Improper claim dependencies
- Missing preamble or transition
## Presentation Format
Present analysis as:
```
CLAIMS ANALYSIS REPORT
======================
Summary:
- Total Claims: 20 (3 independent, 17 dependent)
- Compliance Score: 85/100
- Issues Found: 12 (2 critical, 7 important, 3 minor)
CRITICAL ISSUES (Must Fix):
[Claim 1] Antecedent Basis Error
Issue: Term 'processor' used with 'said' before introduction
Location: "said processor configured to..."
MPEP: 2173.05(e)
Fix: Change to 'the processor' or introduce with 'a processor' first
[Claim 5] Indefinite Term
Issue: Subjective term 'substantially' without definition
Location: "substantially similar to..."
MPEP: 2173.05(b)
Fix: Define 'substantially' in specification or use objective criteria
IMPORTANT ISSUES:
...
MINOR ISSUES:
...
```
## Integration with MPEP
For each issue, the skill can:
1. Search MPEP for relevant guidance
2. Provide specific MPEP section citations
3. Show examiner guidance on similar issues
4. Suggest fixes based on USPTO practice
## Tools Available
- **Read**: To load claims from files
- **Bash**: To run Python analyzer
- **Write**: To save analysis reports