Immutable. This exact content is served forever at /api/v1/blob/4dd0764982034ee4.
--- name: review description: Review a manuscript or chapter as an external reviewer, or run an own-work self-review in a fresh-context clean room, producing anchored findings and a recommendation. allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep, Agent --- # /review — Manuscript Review ## Modes - **external** (default): review another author's work as submitted. - **own-work**: review the user's own draft. The clean room is real, not declared: spawn ONE fresh-context subagent whose prompt contains only the manuscript text (and explicitly listed evidence files), and relay its findings. Never present a same-session read-through as a clean-room review — the drafting conversation is context contamination by definition. ## Evidence boundary Judge the manuscript **as submitted**. Do not use prior chat memory, unstated author intentions, or model background knowledge as evidence for or against a claim. If a claim cannot be assessed from the manuscript and its cited sources, say so — that is itself a finding. ## Findings format Every finding is anchored (section/paragraph or quoted span) and typed: | # | Type | Anchor | Finding | Severity | |---|------|--------|---------|----------| Types: `claim-exceeds-evidence` | `gap-contribution-mismatch` | `method` | `structure` | `clarity` | `citation`. Split findings three ways: defects that block the recommendation, improvements that would strengthen it, and questions the author must answer. Consult `references/argument-checklist.md` for the interrogation checklist and examiner-attack pre-mortem when the review targets argument quality. ## Recommendation vocabulary Exactly one of: `accept` | `minor_revision` | `major_revision` | `reject_resubmit` | `reject` | `no_recommendation`. ## Stop conditions Stop and report a blocker instead of continuing if asked to: fabricate reviewer consensus, citation support, or experimental findings; review text that is not available as submitted; or convert this review into a rewrite — /review never edits the manuscript. ## Constraints 1. Never rewrite or patch the manuscript; output findings only. 2. No emoji. British English. 3. Own-work mode without a subagent available: state plainly that the review is NOT clean-room and label the output accordingly.