pr-comments · diff
git:20260130.f8c0746 to git:20260130.5c0ea14
18 added, 3 removed. Audit A to A.
What this update changes in the checks
No check changed: every fixed check gives the same answer before and after this update.
A tripped check is a label, not a verdict: read the matched text and the lines below. This week's updates that newly trip a check.
---
name: pr-comments
description: Export, preprocess, and fix GitHub PR review comments. Use when user wants to export PR comments, evaluate code reviews, or fix review feedback from CodeRabbit/Gemini bots.
argument-hint: <action> [args...]
disable-model-invocation: true
allowed-tools: Bash(gh *), Bash(jq *), Bash(mkdir *), Bash(sed *), Read, Edit, Glob, Grep
---
# PR Comments Skill
Export GitHub PR review comments, preprocess for evaluation, and fix or reject each review.
## Actions
### 1. Export: `/pr-comments export <owner/repo> <pr-number>`
Export all review comments from a PR to individual markdown files.
```bash
bash .claude/skills/pr-comments/scripts/export.sh $1 $2 $3
```
**Output:** `docs/pr-comments/pr-{number}/` with one file per comment.
### 2. Preprocess: `/pr-comments preprocess <input-dir>`
Clean exported comments for agentic evaluation (removes `<details>` blocks, adds evaluation prompt).
```bash
bash .claude/skills/pr-comments/scripts/batch-preprocess.sh $1
```
**Output:** `{input-dir}-tasks/` with cleaned task files.
- ### 3. Fix: `/pr-comments fix <task-file.md>`
+ ### 3. Analyze: `/pr-comments analyze <tasks-dir>`
+ Show comments grouped by source file with recommended processing order.
+
+ ```bash
+ bash .claude/skills/pr-comments/scripts/analyze.sh $1
+ ```
+
+ **Output:** Table showing which files have multiple comments and line numbers (sorted for bottom-up fixing).
+
+ ### 4. Fix: `/pr-comments fix <task-file.md>`
+
Evaluate a single PR review comment. Read the source file, determine if valid, then fix or explain.
Follow instructions in [review-fix.md](review-fix.md).
- ### 4. Batch: `/pr-comments batch <tasks-dir>`
+ ### 5. Batch: `/pr-comments batch <tasks-dir>`
- Process all task files in a directory, evaluating and fixing each one.
+ Process all task files in a directory. **Groups comments by source file** and fixes bottom-up to avoid line number shifts.
+
+ **Critical:** Multiple comments often target the same file. Batch mode:
+ 1. Groups tasks by source file
+ 2. Sorts by line number descending (bottom-up)
+ 3. Fixes all comments for one file before moving to next
Follow instructions in [review-batch.md](review-batch.md).
## Complete Workflow
```bash
# Step 1: Export comments from PR
/pr-comments export donghaozhang/qcut 102
# Step 2: Preprocess into task files
/pr-comments preprocess docs/pr-comments/pr-102
# Step 3a: Fix single comment
/pr-comments fix docs/pr-comments/pr-102-tasks/comment.md
# Step 3b: Or batch fix all
/pr-comments batch docs/pr-comments/pr-102-tasks
```
## Output Structure
```
docs/pr-comments/
├── README.md
├── pr-102/ # Raw exported comments
│ ├── coderabbitai[bot]_file_L42_123.md
│ └── gemini-code-assist[bot]_file_L50_456.md
└── pr-102-tasks/ # Preprocessed for evaluation
├── coderabbitai[bot]_file_L42_123.md
└── gemini-code-assist[bot]_file_L50_456.md
```
## Supporting Files
- [review-fix.md](review-fix.md) - Single comment evaluation instructions
- [review-batch.md](review-batch.md) - Batch processing instructions
## Requirements
- GitHub CLI (`gh`) - installed and authenticated
- `jq` - JSON processing