Home / serbanghita / plan-critique-skills · GitHub

critique SKILL.md skillB

critique from serbanghita/plan-critique-skills is an agent skill: a SKILL.md folder an AI agent loads when a task calls for it.

Install it, pinned

mdr add serbanghita/plan-critique-skills/critique@git:20260907.caab477

Pins git:20260907.caab477 in mdr.lock. Pin the fingerprint instead.

Audit grade: B, 16 of 17 checks passed
Kind: SKILL.md skill
Repository: serbanghita/plan-critique-skills
Path: skills/critique/SKILL.md
Versions recorded: 5
Latest version: git:20260907.caab477, committed Sep 7, 2026
First version recorded: Jul 28, 2026
Size: 10,306 bytes
Repository stars: 13
License: MIT

Critique the user's plan from plan.md.

Collected from public GitHub. Every version is saved exactly as it was and never changes. Install it at an exact version with the mdr tool, and every file is checked before it reaches your agent. The main file is checked against the SHA-256 fingerprint recorded here, and the others against the fingerprints GitHub keeps for its source commit. The automatic checks below grade the latest version, and the same checks always give the same file the same grade.

What the file says

You are performing an iterative review of the user's execution plan.
Critique the plan, code, architecture, system design, and design patterns.

Fixed rules:

Read the working agreement at [working-agreement.md](../../working-agreement.md) before step 1 and follow it for
the whole run. If that path does not resolve, look for `working-agreement.md` in the project root, then in
`.claude/`. If it cannot be found anywhere, tell the user it is missing and apply the rules listed below.

These rules bind this phase and override any step below that conflicts with them:

1. Be adversarial. Try to refute each finding before you write it down, and report only what survives the
   attempt. A finding you could not refute is worth more than three you did not test.
2. Grade confidence per finding. Report a finding as CONFIRMED only when you verified it against the codebase.
   Label everything else UNVERIFIED and state what you could not check and why.
3. Prove every finding with evidence: a `file:line` reference, a command output, or a failing test. Never assert
   a plausible but unverified conclusion, and never present a guess as a fact.
…

Read the whole file at its exact version.

How to install

The exact contents, by fingerprint

mdr add serbanghita/plan-critique-skills/critique@sha256:9cd83820cbb5ffb0

The line at the top of this page pins the label git:20260907.caab477, which is what most people want. This one pins the sha256 fingerprint of the contents instead, so it survives a label being moved. Either way the exact version is written to mdr.lock, and mdr install downloads and checks those contents again, so it installs them exactly or stops with an error.

Badge

[![mdr](https://markdownregistry.com/badge/art_ekyhpzwgwa6xmnqj.svg)](https://markdownregistry.com/a/art_ekyhpzwgwa6xmnqj)

3 badge image fetches in 30 days. What the badge shows.

Versions

The registry has recorded 5 versions of this file, between Jul 28, 2026 and Sep 7, 2026, about one every 10 days.

version	committed	commit	size	audit
git:20260907.caab477 latest	2026-09-07	caab477	10,306 B	B	view · diff
git:20260907.b55581b	2026-09-07	b55581b	10,281 B	B	view · diff
git:20260808.5924742	2026-08-08	5924742	9,954 B	B	view · diff
git:20260805.45c4430	2026-08-05	45c4430	9,927 B	B	view · diff
git:20260728.4869f12	2026-07-28	4869f12	9,125 B	B	view

Audit of the latest version

B 16 of 17 checks passed. Fixed automatic checks with no AI involved, so the same checks give the same answer every run.

fail: Frontmatter declares a name
pass: Frontmatter block present
pass: Frontmatter declares a description
pass: Size between 200 bytes and 200 KB (10306 bytes)
pass: No zero-width or bidi control characters
pass: No instruction hidden inside an HTML comment
pass: No link to an exfiltration or paste host
pass: No credential-shaped string
pass: No instruction to send local credentials anywhere
pass: No text hidden with inline styles
pass: No prompt-injection phrasing
pass: No curl or wget piped into a shell
pass: No recursive delete of root, home or parent
pass: No instruction to read or print local credentials
pass: No base64 blob over 200 characters
pass: No link to a raw IP address
pass: No script tag

Starting a new one? Use a template for SKILL.md on mdpantry, which passes every one of these checks and says what to change in it.

Source

GitHub

serbanghita/plan-critique-skills · 13 stars · license MIT · pushed 2026-10-20 · branch main

API

GET https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/artifacts/art_ekyhpzwgwa6xmnqj
GET https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/resolve?ref=serbanghita/plan-critique-skills/critique
GET https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/blob/9cd83820cbb5ffb061cb140422a6e7a896b616be45aaa284c0b8944eeff56cb3

Your AI assistant does the legwork. You hear about the deals worth your word. Hand yours the standing instructions at modelranch.com and it joins the network that reads files like this one.

Guides: the SKILL.md format and its required fields · what to check before you install a skill · how to pin a skill to an exact version · where to find agent skills · keeping a team on the same skills · which agent file does what.

More from serbanghita/plan-critique-skills

plan-archive SKILL.md skill

serbanghita/plan-critique-skills · .gemini/skills/plan-archive/SKILL.md · Archive a completed or abandoned plan for future reference