rebuttal-guidance SKILL.md skillA

rebuttal-guidance from hkustdial/supervisor-skills is an agent skill: a SKILL.md folder an AI agent loads when a task calls for it.

Install it, pinned
mdr add hkustdial/supervisor-skills/rebuttal-guidance@git:20260905.198c46c

Pins git:20260905.198c46c in mdr.lock. Pin the fingerprint instead.

Audit grade
A, 17 of 17 checks passed
Kind
SKILL.md skill
Repository
hkustdial/supervisor-skills
Path
skills/rebuttal-guidance/SKILL.md
Versions recorded
2
Latest version
git:20260905.198c46c, committed Sep 5, 2026
First version recorded
Sep 5, 2026
Size
5,307 bytes
Repository stars
12,931
License
a license file GitHub does not identify

Provides actionable peer-review rebuttal guidance (not full rebuttal prose) using conditional persuasion P(Z|X,Y): match reviewer mindset X, recommend strategy Y, optionally ground in manuscript evidence and similar successful historical (review, rebuttal) pairs. Use when the user pastes reviewer comments, asks for rebuttal help, rebuttal guidance, response to reviewers, how to reply to R1.W2, OpenReview rebuttal, or the reviewer ignored the rebuttal.

Collected from public GitHub. Every version is saved exactly as it was and never changes. Install it at an exact version with the mdr tool, and every file is checked before it reaches your agent. The main file is checked against the SHA-256 fingerprint recorded here, and the others against the fingerprints GitHub keeps for its source commit. The automatic checks below grade the latest version, and the same checks always give the same file the same grade.

What the file says

# Rebuttal Guidance

## Overview

This skill delivers **executable rebuttal guidance per concern**: structured plans,
evidence pointers, tone and strategy priorities. It does **not** produce
ready-to-paste rebuttal prose; the author writes the final text.

The core model is **conditional persuasion P(Z=1 | X, Y)**:

- **X**: reviewer mindset (behavior cluster inferred from review text)
- **Y**: rebuttal strategy vector (which tactics to emphasize)
- **Z**: success (score increase or paper accepted)

## When to use

- User pastes Weaknesses / Questions from ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML, EMNLP, etc.
- User asks how to respond to a specific reviewer comment.
- User wants a structured plan before writing rebuttal prose.
- User asks which tone or evidence strategy fits a harsh vs. open reviewer.
- User says "reviewer ignored my rebuttal" and wants to recalibrate.

## When NOT to use

- User wants full rebuttal text copied verbatim → output guidance first; warn
  against blind LLM paste.
- User asks to evaluate a research idea → use `idea-evaluator`.
- User asks for pre-submission paper review → use `pre-submission-reviewer`.
- No review text provided → ask for it first.

---

## Core procedure
…

Read the whole file at its exact version.

How to install

No tool to install first
claude plugin marketplace add https://markdownregistry.com/mp/a/art_uv7d2hf23zcjfebv/cdccf6a9f0de1a459cfbc22943dcd351a913140ce459b2477ea0e7c567070a2a.json

Then /plugin install rebuttal-guidance@markdownregistry-uv7d2hf23zcjfebv in Claude Code. It installs git:20260905.198c46c, the one graded A here, pinned to the commit it was graded at, and leaves it there.

The exact contents, by fingerprint
mdr add hkustdial/supervisor-skills/rebuttal-guidance@sha256:cdccf6a9f0de1a45

The line at the top of this page pins the label git:20260905.198c46c, which is what most people want. This one pins the sha256 fingerprint of the contents instead, so it survives a label being moved. Either way the exact version is written to mdr.lock, and mdr install downloads and checks those contents again, so it installs them exactly or stops with an error.

Badge

mdr badge

[![mdr](https://markdownregistry.com/badge/art_uv7d2hf23zcjfebv.svg)](https://markdownregistry.com/a/art_uv7d2hf23zcjfebv)

2 badge image fetches in 30 days. What the badge shows.

Ask from your agent
claude mcp add --transport http markdownregistry https://markdownregistry.com/mcp/registry

Then ask it: what changed in hkustdial/supervisor-skills/rebuttal-guidance since the version I have? It reads every saved version here, no key and no account. Any agent that speaks MCP can add it.

Got a copy of rebuttal-guidance from somewhere else? Ask it: where did my rebuttal-guidance come from, and what was changed? It names the public original, the version yours is closest to and every changed line. The text is not kept.

Versions

The registry has recorded 2 versions of this file, all committed on Sep 5, 2026.

Watch this file (sign in, one email per new version)

versioncommittedcommitsizeaudit
git:20260905.198c46c latest2026-09-05 198c46c 5,307 BA view · diff
git:20260905.dd394562026-09-05 dd39456 5,351 BA view
Keep it current by itself, install once

Committed this skill to a repository? Install the markdownregistry skill updates app on it, or on all of them. When the registry saves a newer version, a pull request brings your copy to it within minutes, the newest version first, then what changed and any check it newly trips. A copy you edited is never touched, and nothing is deleted.

Install on GitHub

It asks to read and write contents and pull requests, and to read metadata. No workflow file, no Actions setting, nothing runs on your runners. Uninstall it and everything the registry kept about your repository is deleted.

Keep it current by itself

Committed this skill to a repository? Add one workflow file, and when a newer version is saved, a pull request brings your copy to it, the newest version first, then what changed and any check it newly trips. A copy you edited is never touched, and nothing is deleted.

mkdir -p .github/workflows && curl -fsSL https://markdownregistry.com/ci/skill-updates.yml -o .github/workflows/skill-updates.yml

It runs daily on GitHub Actions, no key and no account. Read the workflow before you add it.

Check a whole project

From the root of your project, one line hashes each installed skill's SKILL.md, your AGENTS.md and your CLAUDE.md, and asks the registry once. Only the fingerprints and paths are sent.

sha256sum .claude/skills/*/SKILL.md AGENTS.md CLAUDE.md | curl -s --data-binary @- https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/check-copies

In CI, add --fail-with-body: the answer is 409 when any file is behind, so the step fails and still prints which files.

sha256sum .claude/skills/*/SKILL.md AGENTS.md CLAUDE.md | curl -s --fail-with-body --data-binary @- https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/check-copies

No sha256sum on your machine? shasum -a 256 prints the same lines.

Audit of the latest version

A  17 of 17 checks passed. Fixed automatic checks with no AI involved, so the same checks give the same answer every run.
  • pass: Frontmatter block present
  • pass: Frontmatter declares a name
  • pass: Frontmatter declares a description
  • pass: Size between 200 bytes and 200 KB (5307 bytes)
  • pass: No zero-width or bidi control characters
  • pass: No instruction hidden inside an HTML comment
  • pass: No link to an exfiltration or paste host
  • pass: No credential-shaped string
  • pass: No instruction to send local credentials anywhere
  • pass: No text hidden with inline styles
  • pass: No prompt-injection phrasing
  • pass: No curl or wget piped into a shell
  • pass: No recursive delete of root, home or parent
  • pass: No instruction to read or print local credentials
  • pass: No base64 blob over 200 characters
  • pass: No link to a raw IP address
  • pass: No script tag

Source

GitHub

hkustdial/supervisor-skills · 12,931 stars · license a license file GitHub does not identify · pushed 2026-11-05 · branch main

API

GET https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/artifacts/art_uv7d2hf23zcjfebv
GET https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/resolve?ref=hkustdial/supervisor-skills/rebuttal-guidance
GET https://markdownregistry.com/api/v1/blob/cdccf6a9f0de1a459cfbc22943dcd351a913140ce459b2477ea0e7c567070a2a

Your AI assistant does the legwork. You hear about the deals worth your word. Hand yours the standing instructions at modelranch.com and it joins the network that reads files like this one.

Guides: the SKILL.md format and its required fields · what to check before you install a skill · how to pin a skill to an exact version · where to find agent skills · keeping a team on the same skills · which agent file does what.

More from hkustdial/supervisor-skills

llms.txt llms.txt file
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · llms.txt
git:20260716.1bb65a3 · audit A · 12,931 stars
benchmark-paper-template SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/benchmark-paper-template/SKILL.md · Structures Benchmark and Evaluation papers using the five-pillar framework (Research Gap, Construction Pipeline…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
deep-research SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/deep-research/SKILL.md · Runs a deep, survey-grade literature investigation on a research topic: freezes research questions, searches from…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
drawio-reconstruction SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/drawio-reconstruction/SKILL.md · Reconstructs reference images into high-fidelity, editable Draw.io files with rendered previews: native Draw.io…
git:20260716.1bb65a3 · audit A · 12,931 stars
figure-designer SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/figure-designer/SKILL.md · Advises on the design of the three core figures in a technical paper: the Motivated Example (Figure 1), the Solution…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
idea-evaluator SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/idea-evaluator/SKILL.md · Evaluates a preliminary research idea against a five-dimension framework (Higher, Faster, Stronger, Cheaper, Broader)…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
intro-drafter SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/intro-drafter/SKILL.md · Drafts the Introduction prose for a technical paper, guided internally by a six-paragraph flowchart: background and…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
paper-polish SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/paper-polish/SKILL.md · Polishes existing academic prose while preserving the author's meaning: grammar and flow repair, tone calibration…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
paper-writer SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/paper-writer/SKILL.md · Drafts publishable paper prose from the author's own materials, from a single paragraph to a full manuscript, across…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
pre-submission-reviewer SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/pre-submission-reviewer/SKILL.md · Runs a pre-submission review of a technical paper across five dimensions: macro logic, writing details, English…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
tech-paper-template SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/tech-paper-template/SKILL.md · Structures a technical paper's full logical skeleton using a thinking-template table (research background, limitations…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars
vibe-research-workflow SKILL.md skill
hkustdial/supervisor-skills · skills/vibe-research-workflow/SKILL.md · Guides AI-assisted research across three sub-flows, Vibe Coding, Vibe Figure, and Vibe Writing, with behavioural rules…
git:20260704.6800d4d · audit A · 12,931 stars

Every file in hkustdial/supervisor-skills

Browse by kind, by grade A, or by owner.